Star Trek vs. Star Wars on This Week in Space
AI-written, human-edited.
In the latest episode of This Week in Space, hosts Rod Pyle and Tariq Malik boldly go where many have gone before: the age-old debate of Star Trek vs. Star Wars. These two iconic science fiction franchises have captured the hearts and minds of fans for decades, and now it's time for a showdown.
Rod and Tariq start by sharing their personal experiences with both franchises, discussing their first encounters and how the series have evolved. Tarik reveals a heartwarming story about winning a Star Trek radio contest as a teenager, only to be disqualified for being too young. "There's a whole alternate universe where I went to that premiere and became a super Star Trek megastar or whatever." Tarik laments.
The hosts then dive into the intellectual aspects of each universe, with Rod arguing that Star Trek often focuses on morality plays and philosophical questions, while Star Wars tends to be more of a fun, fantasy-driven space opera. Tarik points out, "Star Trek – it's a merit-based system, right? You have to know what you're talking about to become an officer, an ensign, or whatever, unlike podcasting, as we can prove."
The acting in both franchises is put under the microscope, with the hosts highlighting standout performances and the impact of certain characters and actors. They also examine the iconic spaceships from each universe, noting that Star Trek ships like the Enterprise are more recognizable and have had a more significant cultural impact compared to Star Wars ships, with the exception of the Millennium Falcon. Rod admits, "That is something that always irritated me about Star Wars and, frankly, a lot of sci-fi television. You see this, these, you know, beautiful, looking early 20s. It's a little bit like the Baywatch cast right, comes strutting onto the stage."
As the debate heats up, Rod and Tariq argue that Star Wars has had a more significant influence on popular culture, while Star Trek has been more instrumental in inspiring real-life space exploration and scientific careers. They discuss how both franchises have their merits and have played essential roles in getting people excited about space and science fiction. Tarik passionately states, "I think that for a lot of reasons, both from my own youth experience and the promise of the future and how wide embracing that Star Trek really is, the clear winner. However, I would say that both of these franchises get people excited about space in one way or another, and if that was the only metric, I think that they're both winners, right."
In the end, the hosts conclude that both Star Trek and Star Wars have left an indelible mark on the world of science fiction and beyond. Whether you prefer the cerebral explorations of the Final Frontier or the action-packed adventures in a galaxy far, far away, there's no denying the impact these franchises have had on our culture and our dreams for the future.
To hear more of Rod and Tariq's in-depth analysis and witty banter, including Rod donning a Star Trek uniform and Tariq sporting a Jim Kirk as a T-Rex shirt, be sure to tune in to the full episode of This Week in Space. The hosts also cover exciting space news, such as Voyager 2's latest instrument shutdown, ULA's Vulcan Centaur rocket launch, and a powerful solar flare that could light up the night sky with auroras.
Subscribe so you don't miss an episode: This Week in Space
