Intelligent Machines 839 transcript

Please be advised this transcript is AI-generated and may not be word for word. Time codes refer to the approximate times in the ad-supported version of the show.

Benito Gonzalez [00:00:00]:
It's time for Intelligent Machines. Our guest this week, Riza Martin, is formerly from NotebookLM, which we love. She's created a new app with two other Notebook LM founders called Hawks. A way to kind of get a 24.7feed of news about the things you're interested in. And it's all generated by AI. Next on Intelligent Machines podcasts you love from people you trust. This is Twit. This is Intelligent Machines with Paris Martineau and Jeff Jarvis.

Leo Laporte [00:00:36]:
Episode 839, recorded Wednesday, October 1, 2025. COG, suckers and clankers. It's time for Intelligent Machines, the show. We cover the latest in AI robotics and all the smart doodads and goo gaws surrounding you in this day and age. I don't know how to pronounce it. That's Jeff Jarvis. I know how to say that. He's professor emeritus of journalistic innovation at the Craig Newmark Graduate School at Journalism.

Paris Martineau [00:01:06]:
Craig Craig Craig, New York Newark.

Leo Laporte [00:01:10]:
He's the New York author of the Gutenberg Parenthesis what Would Google Do? Magazine, the Web we weave. Quick, get the display ready. Currently at Montclair State University and SUNY Stony Brook. Great to have you.

Jeff Jarvis [00:01:25]:
Good to see you.

Leo Laporte [00:01:26]:
Paris Martineau is here from Consumer Reports, where she's an investigative journal. She is from Consumer Reports does not speak for Consumer Reports.

Paris Martineau [00:01:33]:
It's true. And when I speak for anyone, I don't know how to pronounce goo gaws either.

Jeff Jarvis [00:01:39]:
Gee, gauze.

Leo Laporte [00:01:41]:
Hey, I'm excited about our guest. We talked about Hux a couple of weeks ago, I think when it first came out. But we've been talking a lot longer about NotebookLM. And in December of this year, three of the stalwarts from NotebookLM decided they were gonna branch out and do their own thing. They tried a couple of things, but ended up creating. I guess it feels like it's kind of related to NotebookLM, an app for Google and iOS that does something very interesting. But you know, why should I explain what it does? We have one of the founders. Yeah, I'll prob get it wrong.

Leo Laporte [00:02:28]:
Anyway, Raisa Martin is co founder of huxhu x e.com hi Raisa. Hello.

Raisa Martin [00:02:36]:
Thank you for having me.

Leo Laporte [00:02:37]:
It's great to have you. Welcome.

Jeff Jarvis [00:02:39]:
And I want to add real quickly. I met Riza when Steven Johnson had me in to see Notebook LLM early on and sat with. It was one of those wonderful things where you sit with lots of smart Google people around the table and they're quizzing you about things like, well, how does this work? How should that work? What do you think about this? And I was so excited about Notebook lm, as you remember. I came back to the show saying what wonderful things it was, and then Rise and Company left. And I was worried for a while that Notebook LM might diminish, but they've been doing good things. And meanwhile, we have Hux, too. So we're doubly blessed now.

Raisa Martin [00:03:16]:
That's right. That's right.

Leo Laporte [00:03:17]:
Yeah. Well, welcome, Raisa. It's great to have you. Raisa or Raisa Ryza.

Raisa Martin [00:03:24]:
Thank you.

Leo Laporte [00:03:25]:
RYZA, you raised $4.6 million in funding, including from Google Research's chief scientist, Jeff Dean. So I'm assuming you left on good terms.

Raisa Martin [00:03:38]:
Yeah, yeah, I think it's. That's actually the question people ask the most is like, hey, that was so surprising. You all left. What happened? And it's not nearly as mysterious, I'd like to think, but we did leave on good terms.

Leo Laporte [00:03:51]:
Yeah. And you and Jason Spielman and Steven Hughes decided to create a company. Your first product was a chatbot, right?

Raisa Martin [00:04:01]:
That's right. That's right. It was a talk to your data chatbot, the very first thing we built. You connected your Zendesk, your HubSpot, your salesforce, your Slack, and you could just chat with the data. And we were building dashboards on top of it to be more proactive. And it went pretty viral on LinkedIn, and we thought it was a pretty good idea. I know, I know. That was the catalyst for moving away from it, where we were like, but do you want to go viral on LinkedIn?

Paris Martineau [00:04:30]:
Always a very important question to ask.

Raisa Martin [00:04:33]:
It's very existential.

Jeff Jarvis [00:04:35]:
So does it exist still?

Raisa Martin [00:04:38]:
Not anymore. After we had some success, and then we had a lot of inbound and people were interested and they wanted to do pilots. We were like, whoa, whoa, wait a second. You know, did we quit Google to build this exact shape and form, or did we kind of jump into something a little too quickly? And we thought, well, you know what? We have a little bit of time to explore a couple of different ideas. And so that's what we did. We were like, okay, let's try something totally different. Probably tried two more different things before landing on Hux as you know it today.

Jeff Jarvis [00:05:07]:
First, the name. I want to hear the derivation of the name.

Leo Laporte [00:05:09]:
Okay, I'm going to tell you, I said what I said, which is probably not true, but I said, oh, maybe it's Aldous Huxley and the Doors of Perception. It's named after the great English novelist.

Raisa Martin [00:05:21]:
Okay. So that is partly true.

Leo Laporte [00:05:23]:
Oh, not so far off.

Raisa Martin [00:05:25]:
That was pretty good. That's pretty good. I try not to say it because I think people always sort of think, oh, that's so dystopian. But.

Paris Martineau [00:05:34]:
It'S the positive dystopian book at least.

Raisa Martin [00:05:36]:
I mean, he did also write the other one, but.

Leo Laporte [00:05:40]:
Oh, yeah, Brave New World. I forgot that one. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:05:44]:
The funny part is, the real origin of the name is we were sitting down, we were thinking about a name, and I'm terrible at names. And Jason goes, you know, we need something brandable that ranks really well in SEO. We could buy the dot com and it has to be four letters. Like it was just like these very specific set of rules. And I was like, okay, so I have to think of a four letter word that I can buy the dot com to that is somehow not taken.

Leo Laporte [00:06:11]:
Yeah, good luck.

Raisa Martin [00:06:12]:
And that's. But that's what we did. And so.

Jeff Jarvis [00:06:15]:
Wow.

Raisa Martin [00:06:15]:
That's why we own Hux.com.

Leo Laporte [00:06:18]:
So did you just try all possible combinations of four letter words or.

Raisa Martin [00:06:22]:
Well, eventually he came up with some other rules. Like one of his rules was there needs to be an X. And you know, we just followed him. We were like, go ahead.

Leo Laporte [00:06:30]:
And it should be pronounceable. I think that's fair. It shouldn't be a homonym with any other English word because then you would know. Not know how to spell it. So it's got to be kind of somewh. Somewhat transparent in terms of spelling. Yeah, but there's no other root to it. There's no other.

Raisa Martin [00:06:49]:
I liked Hux when it, when it came up because I, Aldous Huxley is one of my favorite authors. And I was like, oh, this feels. This feels good, right? This feels good. The funniest story about the name, you know, in terms of just like being able to pronounce it. I once had somebody come up to me and they said, you know, is it Taiwanese?

Leo Laporte [00:07:06]:
Taiwanese, yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:07:08]:
At first I was like, is it Hu. Sh? I was like, no, but thanks for asking.

Leo Laporte [00:07:12]:
I wonder what that means though. Let's figure that out.

Paris Martineau [00:07:16]:
I like that everyone has a different theory about the name that does indicate something.

Raisa Martin [00:07:22]:
Yeah, exactly.

Leo Laporte [00:07:23]:
So we should probably describe what Hux does. Yes.

Jeff Jarvis [00:07:26]:
Before we go much further. That was my fault.

Leo Laporte [00:07:28]:
It is an app and it's kind of Akin to NotebookLM. I would think that a lot of people use NotebookLM to do something similar.

Raisa Martin [00:07:37]:
I think so. I think it looks a little bit like NotebookLM, I think because it's the closest. But It's a little bit different in the sense that when you think of Notebook, maybe you think about creating podcasts. Hux is more about creating radio stations. And so it's really about always listening to something live about your interests, your emails, your calendar, your newsletters you're subscribed to, listening to it live and having it just be interactive by default.

Leo Laporte [00:08:06]:
But no commercials.

Raisa Martin [00:08:08]:
No commercials at this time.

Leo Laporte [00:08:10]:
Yeah. Well, that might be something to hope for actually down the road. So you pick the topics. I have Hux. I've been using Hux. It's kind of fun. In fact, I think we didn't.

Jeff Jarvis [00:08:19]:
We played it a little bit last week.

Leo Laporte [00:08:20]:
Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:08:22]:
Thank you.

Leo Laporte [00:08:22]:
Yeah, I think it's a really interesting idea. And I know of a number of people, including Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, who do this with their podcasts. They kind of create something with AI they can listen to in the car. Here's the Big Tech Roundup now. It says it wants my microphone. Is that so I can talk to it or.

Raisa Martin [00:08:45]:
Yes, yes.

Leo Laporte [00:08:46]:
Okay. So I can ask questions of it as we listen.

Raisa Martin [00:08:48]:
Good afternoon, Leo. Welcome to Big Tech Roundup.

Leo Laporte [00:08:51]:
Time to check what's new with Apple, Amazon, Tesla, Microsoft Meta Alphabet, and Nvidia. Now, I should say, gather the latest updates. I should not like this because it's competing a little bit with what we do.

Raisa Martin [00:09:05]:
Well, I do. I do think that in the early days, we see a lot of sort of people replicating things that exist, because that's what we know. But I think the point of making things like this is, is for the stuff that doesn't exist yet. And so one of my favorites is this dad that made a radio station about his kid's school.

Paris Martineau [00:09:25]:
Oh, that's cool.

Raisa Martin [00:09:25]:
So he doesn't have to check his email anymore for the events or he doesn't have to miss events. He just listens to the school radio every morning.

Leo Laporte [00:09:32]:
So you can tie it into your exist your calendar and your email and all of that.

Raisa Martin [00:09:37]:
Yes, exactly.

Paris Martineau [00:09:38]:
This could be a good way to listen to all those newsletters that I subscribe to but don't.

Jeff Jarvis [00:09:45]:
Good thought, Paris. Excellent thought.

Raisa Martin [00:09:49]:
I like that it does do that. So if you connect your email and it sees you have newsletters, it will unpack the newsletters for you in your daily briefing.

Leo Laporte [00:09:57]:
The other thing, I like privacy.

Paris Martineau [00:09:59]:
Like on this, I mean, because you say connect your email.

Raisa Martin [00:10:01]:
Yeah. So we don't actually store your email or your calendar data. We don't. We certainly don't train on it. We access it in real time just to present the info back to you.

Leo Laporte [00:10:14]:
Unlike NotebookLM, one of the complaints people have about NotebookLM is we're getting sick of those two people. You have a huge number. I don't know. I can show this a huge number of voices that you can choose from. So you don't have to get bored with the same two people. Is it always two people talking?

Raisa Martin [00:10:32]:
Right now it is two people talking. We actually experimented for a while with multiple speakers, more than two, and we discovered that almost nobody chose more than two.

Jeff Jarvis [00:10:42]:
What's the Steven Johnson told us about how the voices were created with the prosody of real people. How did you create these voices?

Raisa Martin [00:10:51]:
So for us, a lot of what we build in HUX is commercially available APIs, and so we ourselves don't train the voice models. However, one of the things that is true is that there is still a lot of work to get them to the quality where they are. It's not as straightforward as just like taking a voice and then saying, okay, say these words. Because of the exact thing I was telling you before the show, Jeff, which is certain voices are good for certain types of content. And that is just such a unique point in time we're at right now where there are some voices that are better in news, some are better at sports, some are great at, like, science, but then you have to sort of draw those out and it just makes the quality a lot better.

Jeff Jarvis [00:11:36]:
So talk about the fact that the microphone's on and you can talk to it. What's your intended? Maybe Leo can demonstrate this to put him on the spot. What's the use you envision for that? Two way.

Raisa Martin [00:11:46]:
Yeah. So I think about this a lot in the context I'm a big user of ChatGPT voice, but I noticed that the way that I was using ChatGPT in particular is it was a very pull kind of interaction. I have to take my phone out, I have to start the topic, I have to start talking, and then ChatGPT responds. And then there's this natural back and forth, back and forth, forth, and then if I stop, it stops altogether. But the quality of that conversation is only as good as what I bring to it. Whereas we had this idea of like, what if you just flip the script? What if you could know enough about a person such that when they come to the app, you already have something for them that naturally, like, requires no work on their part and it's just passive. Right. In the same way that we listen to podcasts.

Raisa Martin [00:12:32]:
Right. I could just play something, I could listen to to it, but the added riff is that when you do find something interesting or you have a question, or you have feedback, you have that option as well. And so we think that this passive layer is actually a really, really, very powerful interaction layer.

Jeff Jarvis [00:12:48]:
It's a really good point because I tended to stare at Alexa and not know what to say.

Raisa Martin [00:12:54]:
Well, that's the. I think that's the big lesson from a lot of, like the last generation sort of voice assistant stuff, right. Where I think about my Google home all the time. I think I'm fairly tech savvy, but I only use that thing for one task, which is to set an alarm. If I were, to be honest with you, I don't really know what else it could do. It's very hard for you to learn it. And so there is, I think, a pretty steep onboarding to things that don't have a UI or an obvious one.

Leo Laporte [00:13:20]:
There's also kind of a huge amount of. For instance, I have now Andrej Kaparthy, which we love Andre's Things. There's a whole channel devoted to his Twitter account, which I think is wild. I mean, there's a huge number of selections. Can you also create your own stations out of whole cloth? Could you say, I want to follow this person?

Raisa Martin [00:13:39]:
Yes, absolutely. And so the reason why we have so many of those is to try to inspire people to create their own. And then you'll have ideas, right? And you can create one from subreddits. You could use Twitter.

Leo Laporte [00:13:52]:
That's a good idea.

Raisa Martin [00:13:53]:
Yeah.

Leo Laporte [00:13:53]:
You could do the Sovereign Citizen subreddit radio show. How about that? Paris. What do you think?

Paris Martineau [00:13:58]:
Listen, that would be.

Raisa Martin [00:14:01]:
And you can do collections. You could do these combinations of things or, you know, what we found is most popular is people just write exactly what they want, you know, and just type it out. It's like, here, I want a radio station, blah, blah. And then you have it.

Leo Laporte [00:14:15]:
Yeah. Pretty amazing. Wow, Nice.

Jeff Jarvis [00:14:19]:
Neil, can you ask a question of it? I'm curious to hear.

Leo Laporte [00:14:21]:
I was going to see if I can get this on my computer, which might make it a little bit easier for us to. To look at it as opposed to. Okay, I've got iPhone mirroring going and let's see.

Paris Martineau [00:14:36]:
Yeah, I guess while we're doing that, I feel like audio is really. Oh, okay. You got.

Leo Laporte [00:14:43]:
So what do you want? What did you want me to do? So I was just showing.

Jeff Jarvis [00:14:45]:
I was just get into a dialogue with it, see where it goes.

Leo Laporte [00:14:47]:
Oh, okay. I was going to show how I can create a station.

Jeff Jarvis [00:14:50]:
That too. That too, yeah.

Leo Laporte [00:14:51]:
But you know, I can go back out here. So let me go back to my home and let's see, here's. It would be fun to do a Reddit sovereign citizens thing, but let's take a Reddit instead of Red Face. It's gonna be really confused. Oh, it's not available from the imac. So the Mac, I can't talk to it from the Mac. I have to do it on the phone. And I don't want to keep holding up the phone to demonstrate this.

Leo Laporte [00:15:18]:
But give us an example. How would we. We would be listening and I would say, okay, but let's go deeper in that subject. Something like that.

Raisa Martin [00:15:28]:
Yeah, I think that's actually the number one use case. I listen to quite a few of these every day. And so, for example, I listen to tokenomics a lot. Tokenomics is a station I created to keep track of token pricing.

Leo Laporte [00:15:42]:
Wow.

Raisa Martin [00:15:43]:
As a person with a startup, I can't.

Leo Laporte [00:15:45]:
That's pretty granular. Yeah, no, that's what's really interesting. Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:15:49]:
And sometimes I'll just interrupt it. I'll be like, no, I only care about did anthropic get cheaper.

Leo Laporte [00:15:55]:
Right.

Raisa Martin [00:15:55]:
Okay, well, let me see. Let's check the show notes.

Leo Laporte [00:15:58]:
So if you're creating a station, you can type in what you want to hear about. There's also a button to enable web search. So you're using. You maybe don't want to talk about which model you're using, but you're using commercially available models to do all of this, is that right?

Raisa Martin [00:16:13]:
Yeah, that's right.

Leo Laporte [00:16:14]:
Do you want to tell us which models?

Raisa Martin [00:16:17]:
No, but what I will tell you. And people ask us this all the time, especially since we left Google. They always assume, oh, you guys must be like an all Google shop. And I, I try to tell people, you know, if you spend enough time with these models, you discover what they're good at. And to build something that is good is still pretty complicated today. And you will naturally find utility for pretty much all the models out there.

Leo Laporte [00:16:41]:
Right.

Raisa Martin [00:16:42]:
That's the reality under. Under the hood.

Leo Laporte [00:16:44]:
So I could, for instance, add Jeff's Buzz Machine blog and have. And listen to a show about your blog, or add a variety of websites or RSS feeds or x handles or URLs of any kind. And that's pretty cool. I mean, you could basically take any information sources on the Internet and turn it into a live stream.

Raisa Martin [00:17:07]:
Yeah, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [00:17:08]:
But it's more than that. The fact that it's a dialogue, you could say, oh, explain that to me. Find out more about this.

Leo Laporte [00:17:14]:
This really highlights the difference between you and me, Jeff. I just wanna listen. This to me is like a radio station. You know, I imagine, like I talk enough every day, maybe that' but I don't. I don't. So I. You probably have some more granular information about how people use this, but I would expect people use it kind of like radio in their car. If you have a commute, you might turn on the stage.

Leo Laporte [00:17:39]:
Is that how you use it? Ryza is like you turn on your token station and as you're coming to work, things like that, or brushing your teeth or whatever.

Raisa Martin [00:17:48]:
I think this is the number one insight we actually built hacks off of, is when we built the earliest, earliest version of this before I was even to the point where we are today. We discovered very quickly that people just used the first thing in the morning and it didn't matter who the person was. They were like, well, instead of checking my phone this morning, I'm just going to listen to it. I'm going to listen while I brush my teeth.

Leo Laporte [00:18:12]:
Yeah, I mean, I already do that. My wife does it with up first, you know, or the daily. You know, she's getting ready in the morning and she'll put that on. It's a habit everybody has. Or if you have a commute, which many of us don't no longer have, that's what you do. You turn on the radio. If I were radio, I'd be very nervous about this because, I mean, you already have music stations, you know, on Spotify and so forth. Now you've got talk stations.

Leo Laporte [00:18:39]:
There really is nowhere left for radio to go.

Paris Martineau [00:18:43]:
Are you already. What other insights are you seeing from users and how they're using this?

Raisa Martin [00:18:50]:
So I think the second most surprising thing. So the first insight was like, okay, wow, this is super interesting. People are using it in the morning. But then when we kept looking deeper, we discovered there were people who were using it multiple times a day. Multiple times a day, very long periods of time. And then I asked, well, why are you doing that? And they said, well, it's nice to just listen to it while I'm working. You know, it's keeping me company.

Leo Laporte [00:19:12]:
Yeah, it's a radio station. Look, I welcome working in radio for 40 years. I understand that people aren't really necessarily actively listening. You're keeping them company. They're, you know, they're kind of. It's in the background.

Paris Martineau [00:19:24]:
A major reversal from the White House on drug tariffs and quiet but significant move.

Leo Laporte [00:19:30]:
This is Hux. Oh, listen to the Capitol desk. Before we get to the very latest, it's worth just to give people an example.

Paris Martineau [00:19:36]:
I thought it was Jeff's TV for us. As of this morning, Jeff is normally.

Leo Laporte [00:19:39]:
When we're not on everything from heavy trucks to pharmaceuticals, compounding the economic pressure. You can also. This is good. Start with the big listen at 2x.

Paris Martineau [00:19:49]:
The Senate blocking competing funding bills from the House and Senate.

Leo Laporte [00:19:50]:
I wouldn't, but my wife does. She's in a hurry.

Paris Martineau [00:19:54]:
Shutdown can be avoided. While Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries says Democrats.

Leo Laporte [00:19:56]:
Are ready, Jeffries says Democrats are ready to negotiate.

Paris Martineau [00:20:00]:
The White House users in those two buckets, we identified kind of like the morning users as well as the people who are listening for long periods of time. Are they just listening or are you starting to see people engage?

Leo Laporte [00:20:13]:
Yeah. How much do they talk back to it? Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:20:15]:
I love this question. And I think it also gets to where we're at in this current moment, in, I don't know, time. But we at first saw primarily passive listening. But the longer the user was a user of Hux, the more their interactions increased.

Leo Laporte [00:20:33]:
See, they become. You turn them into Jeffs.

Raisa Martin [00:20:37]:
Exactly. You turn them into Jeffs. But I really liked. I really like this insight because it was super cool. When you talk to these people, they were like, well, at first I didn't know what the button was for. Right. Is what people normally said. They're like, why is there a microphone button?

Leo Laporte [00:20:49]:
What's the join button?

Jeff Jarvis [00:20:50]:
Yeah. It confused me at first because it was talking to me and I didn't expect it to talk to me.

Raisa Martin [00:20:55]:
Yes. And I think that the funny part is we've renamed.

Jeff Jarvis [00:20:58]:
Let's check what's.

Raisa Martin [00:20:59]:
We've renamed that particular button so many times because of this feedback where people were like, I don't know what the button does, but once they discover what it is, it just changes everything.

Leo Laporte [00:21:07]:
You can't stop using it.

Jeff Jarvis [00:21:09]:
Here's the thing. I'm researching the beginnings of radio right now. And in the earliest days of radio, it was controlled by amateurs, later known as hams, but it was amateurs who built not only receiving stations, but also transmitting stations.

Leo Laporte [00:21:22]:
That's what Marconi thought radio was going to be.

Jeff Jarvis [00:21:24]:
Exactly. It was called radio telephony. That was the full name of radio. Radio meant radiation, and so it was telephony on radiation. And until the US Navy and corporations screwed it all up and made radio what it was, the province of huge corporations. It could have been much smaller. It could have been like early blogs in the province of conversation.

Leo Laporte [00:21:46]:
Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:21:47]:
Yeah.

Leo Laporte [00:21:48]:
So go ahead.

Paris Martineau [00:21:50]:
Prepare for these, I guess, more general channels, I guess, the ones that users aren't specifically seeking out and saying, hey, go to the sovereign citizen subreddit and read me this. Where are you guys getting the information from? And kind of, how are you sourcing or attributing that?

Raisa Martin [00:22:06]:
So a lot of the way that it works underneath the hood is when you look at how you can create a station, you can essentially just, like, pull from URLs. You can even upload text, or you can just have it search the web. And so it's pretty similar to how you might imagine if you had to manually construct this. You're like, okay, I want to listen to radio about token pricing. You go do a web search on what is token pricing today? Maybe you search specifically what the different companies are. You compile that research, and then you create a podcast or in this case, a live radio station about it. So it's just web search.

Paris Martineau [00:22:42]:
Okay. I think some skeptics have warned that generative audio or conversational hosts can mislead users because they sound like, authoritative, even when they're wrong. I guess. How are you guys approaching this? And, like, how do you design for kind of keeping that awareness with the users?

Raisa Martin [00:23:03]:
Yeah, I think that's a question that we dealt with a lot on Notebook as well, because people could upload any sources and then you could create audio about those sources. But there is a certain level that you want to hold or a bar that you want to hold where it's like, okay, as people ask to talk about topics and you search what's on the Internet, how do you know whether something is accurate versus completely made up? And so we actually have a step in the flow where we add a little bit of editorial, where we cross check for factuality, we cross check for things like recency, whether or not there's conflicting information. If there's multiple perspectives, we say the different perspectives. And the only I would say, downside to that is because it is audio, you kind of have to listen to the whole thing before it gets through all of that.

Leo Laporte [00:23:51]:
There's also no way to click a referring link. So unlike, you know, web searches using AI, you don't link back to the original source material.

Raisa Martin [00:24:01]:
Yes, not yet. I think that is something that will probably ship in the next month or so. It was not. Yeah, it was not something that we were able to get in for this release just because the way that we get the referring links right now, it wasn't super easy for us. So we've had to do a lot of cleanup before we could make it just as simple as a tap for the user.

Leo Laporte [00:24:20]:
So you'd like to be able to send people back to the source of the material? Yes, because that's a big concern, of course, for a lot of content creators, including Consumer Reports, I'm sure, and others is that AIs like this are taking their material without referring people back to the original source.

Raisa Martin [00:24:36]:
Yeah. And I think users also want to know.

Paris Martineau [00:24:39]:
Right.

Raisa Martin [00:24:39]:
Like if you're hearing, for example, here's like the discussion, this person said this, this person said that. And you might want to do a double click into one of those arguments. It's a lot easier to just have the link there and then read more about it.

Leo Laporte [00:24:52]:
Right, right.

Jeff Jarvis [00:24:53]:
So what else is next for Hux?

Raisa Martin [00:24:55]:
So right now we're just learning honestly, like what people are doing with the new version, what kind of stations they're creating. We have a discord that's over 4,000 people now and we actually have a specific channel where people are sharing their stations. I think the cool thing is just to see, you know, every day I feel like people turn the page on like what's stations are possible. And it's kind of cool to just see like the, the things that people are sharing with their friends and their family.

Jeff Jarvis [00:25:21]:
That is very cool business model.

Paris Martineau [00:25:25]:
Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:25:26]:
I mean, I think we're so early. I don't want to. The thing I don't want to try to do as much as I can is I don't want to pay gate too early.

Jeff Jarvis [00:25:36]:
Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:25:37]:
Because I think we lose out on so much of learning, like what people really want. Then I say that because of just the exact story I told you, which was it turns out if you use it longer and longer, it changes your interaction pattern. And I just don't think I could have learned that as easily if I didn't even know what the minimum number of listens was. Right, right.

Jeff Jarvis [00:25:57]:
So I love this and I'm in favor of the kind of openness that it encourages. Have you heard yet from whining, entitled journalists saying, oh, you're stealing all my hard work and my beautiful words?

Raisa Martin [00:26:13]:
I have not yet. I think about this a lot just because of the nature of kind of like, okay, if you scrape information from the Internet and you put it all together, how do you give credit back to the people or the original sources? I think links and citations are the number one step there. But in general, I think we just have to take it day by day. I mean, we have to first prove that it's even interesting Enough.

Jeff Jarvis [00:26:39]:
And you're. Well, you're also enabling people to. I think, I think it's Paris's idea about newsletters, right? I subscribe to them, I want to read them, but I don't. So you're enabling a new path for them. In fact, I could imagine media companies saying, please, can I create a media company should create stations with you. Yeah, right. Because it'll promote what they do.

Leo Laporte [00:27:00]:
So I'm looking on the discord with the channel, with user contributed channels. And it's great the diversity. Here's one. From a libertarian Point of View, VR News, a public station for Crypto Web3 and blockchain related news. I mean, I think you've hit on something that people really like and really want, but at some point you are going to have to monetize it. Do you have thoughts about how you might do that with a subscription or advertising?

Raisa Martin [00:27:33]:
So I think this is maybe a little bit too forward in the future, but one of the thoughts that I had was, you know what's interesting about Hax is it knows what you are listening to. It knows what types of things you've already listened to. It is a naturally good filter for advertising. And the reason I say that is because, you know, my number one problem with ads is when I don't like them, right? I don't mind it if it's a good ad, but it really bugs me when I, you know, I watch TV and there's an ad that's meant for everybody. It's like that's when I'm on my phone and I'm not paying attention. But it's interesting to kind of think about a platform where even as an advertiser you don't have to create the ad. You can just say, here's my product, right? It's Blue Bottle. It's cold brew, it's in the Bay Area and it can automatically self target to people that that's relevant to.

Raisa Martin [00:28:20]:
And let's say I already know that Raisa buys a lot of coffee and she drinks cold brew exclusively. Then you can generate the ad dynamically, like in that moment, in the same way the content is generated. And you can just say, hey, real quick, in between this segment and this segment, let me tell you, Blue bottles having a 25% off sale, but only in Palo Alto, right? And it's just like one of those things, which is you don't have to create an ad like that and the user doesn't have to be mad that it's an ad that's not relevant to them. So it helps, I think both sides.

Jeff Jarvis [00:28:50]:
That's cool thinking.

Leo Laporte [00:28:51]:
Do you find that people listen to many different stations or that they tend to end up on a single station that they listen to all day? Or how is. How does the use vary?

Raisa Martin [00:29:01]:
I think people definitely have their favorites, sort of. Everybody seems to love Daily Briefing, which I, I'll be very honest with you, I was very surprised. The idea of listening emails. Yeah just like listening to email is just such a weird paradigm. It's like why would anybody want to do it? But I think it's true. Like people are just drowning in info and we just need all the help we can get. And so people love Daily Brief. And then I think everybody's got their own flavor of station, which is like there's like the sports people, the crypto people, the finance people and the news people.

Jeff Jarvis [00:29:31]:
How many channels are there now?

Raisa Martin [00:29:34]:
You know, I don't know. I haven't looked at how stations have been created. Many. Many for sure.

Leo Laporte [00:29:41]:
Many. I would have, I would have hooked up my email in my calendar, but I don't use Google or Outlook and I guess that's just the easiest.

Jeff Jarvis [00:29:48]:
That's because he's weird.

Leo Laporte [00:29:49]:
Path of least resistance. Well, I know everybody. Most people do use. Use Gmail. That's by far the number one. But I would just put in a.

Jeff Jarvis [00:29:57]:
Still on AOL mail. But he doesn't want to.

Leo Laporte [00:29:59]:
No, I use the fast mail. I use an IMAP server and I would, I would just like it if I could use CalDAV and, and, and IMAP as an input into this just for your developers, just to let them know.

Raisa Martin [00:30:10]:
I'll. I'll make a note.

Leo Laporte [00:30:12]:
Yeah, yeah. Because then I would probably do the Daily Briefing. I think that would be kind. I think I would do that. You know, I'm missing out now.

Raisa Martin [00:30:18]:
I feel sorry. Forward it to Gmail.

Leo Laporte [00:30:23]:
I do actually that's what I ended up doing for some other. Because almost everybody, it's just so much easier to. They have the API. Once you understand the API, it's very easy to write it. So I understand why people do that. And so a lot of apps, I have to just forward it to a special account. Well, Ryza, I thank you for your time. I think this is very interesting.

Leo Laporte [00:30:44]:
I think people should try it. It is an app on iOS and Android, generally speaking. I think you would want the iOS app if you have the choice. It looks like the. It's a little bit more capable and stable, but. Yeah, but they're both there and they're both working and what an interesting way to get your latest news and information. You know, and if I were in radio still, I would be upset. I'd be very worried.

Leo Laporte [00:31:14]:
I'm a little worried as a podcaster, to be honest. It's on the app Store for iPhone and iPad. Are you planning a Windows version? There is an Android version or a Mac OS or Chrome OS version.

Raisa Martin [00:31:26]:
We're definitely thinking about a web version. I think people ask for it a lot.

Leo Laporte [00:31:29]:
Good. Yeah.

Raisa Martin [00:31:30]:
Yeah. So probably.

Jeff Jarvis [00:31:32]:
Can I ask one more question?

Leo Laporte [00:31:34]:
Of course.

Jeff Jarvis [00:31:36]:
So you don't say what platform you're built on and platforms are leapfrogging each other regularly and they're kind of commodified. I think the excitement in AI is going to be where you are in the application layer on top of that. But when you build a top one version of one platform and either that platform goes away like GPT4O or a better version comes along, how hard is it to port what you've done to a different foundation model?

Raisa Martin [00:32:08]:
It takes us about a day.

Leo Laporte [00:32:10]:
Wow. Yeah, it sounds like they've done it already. They did it once before.

Raisa Martin [00:32:17]:
We've done it many, many, many times.

Jeff Jarvis [00:32:19]:
Wow, that's fascinating.

Leo Laporte [00:32:22]:
I wish I could ask you which models are best for this kind of content?

Raisa Martin [00:32:29]:
Well, you can always ask me on the side extraction.

Jeff Jarvis [00:32:31]:
What are the features that make a model good for this? Let's make it generic.

Raisa Martin [00:32:35]:
Well, the thing about Hux is what makes the content good is a multi step process that happens over a period of time that is not visible to the user. So even things, even things like thinking about, well, who is Leo? What would Leo like? You know, what are things that Leo likes and then things that he might like. Right. So those, those types of explorations and then trying to figure out how to write scripts, you know, for Leo specifically. Right. Like the individual person, the tasks are not as simple as just like generating the script script or just researching. And I think that's where we see a lot of some of these apps fall apart, is just like you think it's the simple sort of like research and production. I mean, you know.

Raisa Martin [00:33:19]:
Right. Like it's not that I think if you had to really internalize that you are creating content for an audience of one and your job was just to make it look good. Yeah.

Leo Laporte [00:33:32]:
And I'm sure that you have in a meeting or two said, what if we did this for music? Any thoughts along those lines?

Raisa Martin [00:33:41]:
I think music is cool. I think there's like a lot of APIs that you could try now. I think 11 labs just released one. I think I saw another one.

Leo Laporte [00:33:49]:
I feel like you could do a better job than Spotify of picking songs for me to listen to. I guess that's a whole different business is what I'm saying.

Raisa Martin [00:33:56]:
I do. I do think that it's a different business. I think it's cool. I mean, I think people.

Leo Laporte [00:34:00]:
But you like speech.

Raisa Martin [00:34:02]:
I like speech. And it's an easy first one.

Leo Laporte [00:34:05]:
Yeah, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [00:34:06]:
First one. Note that. Ah, so your cost is mainly tokens now.

Raisa Martin [00:34:11]:
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [00:34:14]:
What you pay attention to every day. Sorry.

Leo Laporte [00:34:16]:
Leo was at NotebookLM at the very beginning. She left in December to join Jason Spielman and Steven Hughes to create Hux H U X E dot com. You can go there and. And get a link to the download and put it on your device. And listen, the next time we're not on the air, please don't do it before you listen to all of our shows. Okay. First, thank you, Raisa. It's great to talk to you.

Raisa Martin [00:34:44]:
Thanks for having me. Thanks, everyone. Take care.

Leo Laporte [00:34:47]:
Thanks for the product, the app. It's really great.

Raisa Martin [00:34:49]:
Yeah, of course. See you.

Leo Laporte [00:34:51]:
See you later. We'll continue with Intelligent Machines in just a moment. AI News is next. Thank you. Oh, she's gone.

Benito Gonzalez [00:34:59]:
Oh, she just left. Okay.

Jeff Jarvis [00:35:01]:
She knew how to do it. Most people don't know what most people sit around.

Paris Martineau [00:35:04]:
Fantastic.

Leo Laporte [00:35:06]:
What do you think? Would you use this?

Jeff Jarvis [00:35:09]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [00:35:10]:
Me? No.

Leo Laporte [00:35:10]:
Probably.

Jeff Jarvis [00:35:11]:
No, I, I.

Paris Martineau [00:35:12]:
Maybe for newsletters.

Jeff Jarvis [00:35:14]:
I think the newsletter idea is a good one.

Paris Martineau [00:35:15]:
I think newsletters. It could be that because. But I guess it would be like newsletters that aren't specifically related to work just because I. It's the same problem I have with using anything AI related to primary work functions is just the hallucinations are too hard to pick.

Leo Laporte [00:35:36]:
Oh, we should have asked her how they get around that. Darn it. I wish I'd asked about that. Yeah. I have not seen any false stuff in here so far.

Paris Martineau [00:35:46]:
Well, that's the thing, Leo, is you. The way that the false cities make it in outputs from LLMs these days is not immediately apparent. Like, it's presented in ways that unless you already know the answer of what. Like it is getting wrong. It's, like, hard to immediately suss out.

Jeff Jarvis [00:36:09]:
But don't forget she comes from Notebook LM A B. It's going off. Off a source that you give it. It's. It's rag, like. Right.

Paris Martineau [00:36:17]:
Well, but the.

Jeff Jarvis [00:36:20]:
The mistakes in general, sir.

Paris Martineau [00:36:21]:
She was saying, like, for example, her token podcast is based on search. So I guess they'd be kind of like a thinking model, you know, like it's not coming from a set.

Leo Laporte [00:36:29]:
No, that's right. There's a variety of ways to. To create new stations and the ones that they have pre provided it's not necessarily immediately clear how they're creating them. So there could be easily. Could be hallucinations. That's not the thing that bothers me. The thing that bothers me and maybe it's because I'm a broadcaster. I just.

Leo Laporte [00:36:46]:
It's a little cringy for me. Same problem with NotebookLM to listen to AI voices, you see.

Jeff Jarvis [00:36:51]:
But I think it's the use case that matters. That's why I went after the question of dialogue. I could see so as I harass Leo every week now because I have a dozen pre print papers that I put in the rundown that he ignores and they're complicated and I could see using this to summarize those for me because a lot I don't understand. Or I could ask it then questions explain this. What does that mean? It not wouldn't be something that when I'm doing research, I'm doing it on. On, on while I used to say print. But I'm doing it in a way I can underline and look things up and go back and cite and so on and so forth. When I'm doing my interests, that's different and I'm a little less persnickety.

Leo Laporte [00:37:35]:
Yeah. Let's take a break. We will have more in just a little bit. You're listening to Intelligent Machines, our show today, brought to you by Monarch Money. In this day and age of financial uncertainty, shall we put it that way in the stock market? And you're just going, what's going on? And you know, my investments, my savings, my retirement, this is what I live on. So it's really important that I know where. Where my money's going. And I am thrilled to have found Monarch Money.

Leo Laporte [00:38:04]:
If you want to feel organized and confident in your finances, this is a solution for you. Most people can't even name all of their where their money is, all the different financial accounts. They certainly, almost anybody, if you ask them can say, well, what's your net worth? They won't really know or they'll make up, they'll hallucinate, they'll make up a number that isn't maybe necessarily related to fact. Especially with the volatility in the markets lately. If you've been putting it off, I want to highly recommend Monarch Money. Monarch is the all in one personal finance tool that Takes your entire financial life, combines it into one simple, easy to read, clean interface. And you can do it on your laptop, you can do it on your phone. You know, the earliest days of computing, one of the things everybody was doing was balancing your checkbook.

Leo Laporte [00:38:52]:
You know, you would get that. There was a lot of programs like Quicken that you would set up. This is for people with busy lives who do not want to enter in all of that data, who just want to hook up their accounts and have it all be automatic. And Monarch does all the heavy lifting. You link your accounts in minutes and you do it in a very secure way, by the way. No concern about that at all. And then you get clear data visuals, you get smart categorization. I actually set up the budgeting so it automatically assigns everything.

Leo Laporte [00:39:24]:
It's very smart about it. So without doing any actual work, any budgeting, I can see what I'm spending on entertainment, on food, on clothing. You get real control over your money and where it's going. And you don't have to touch a spreadsheet ever again. Don't leave money on the table. It's easy to become complacent, especially you young people. You got a job, you're making good money, you don't need to track every dollar. But I can tell you as an old person, ignoring your finances now will cost you down the road.

Leo Laporte [00:39:53]:
You can miss opportunities to save more, to invest better, to hit your financial goals faster. And this is the best way to do it. Monarch is not just another finance app. It's a tool real professionals and experts love. Named best budgeting app of 2025 by the Wall Street Journal, Forbes said it's the best app for couples. I really love that idea. You can each enter your accounts in there and have a unified look at how you are doing as a family. CNBC put it in the top fintech companies in the world.

Leo Laporte [00:40:23]:
And there is a very active, passionate Reddit community which I subscribe to, of over 34,000 users. And by the way, it's not just us. Monarch takes a look at this and this is shaping how the products develop. They really want to listen to their customers. Money can break couples. Monarch and bring them together. Monarch gives your partner full access to your shared dashboard, linked accounts, budgets, goals, spending activity all in one place. No extra cost.

Leo Laporte [00:40:51]:
You can even give access to your financial advisor at no extra cost. That's great too. Don't let financial opportunities slip through the cracks. Use the code im@monimalmoney.com in your browser. You're going to get half off your first year. That's 50% off your first year. @monarchmoney.com with the code IAM for intelligent machines. Cannot recommend this more highly.

Leo Laporte [00:41:16]:
Monarchmoney.com use the offer code IAM for 50% off your first year. All the world is a talking about the new Sora 2. I can't get in and it's an invite only. But boy, I bookmarked a lot of people.

Jeff Jarvis [00:41:36]:
It's also Apple only.

Leo Laporte [00:41:39]:
Oh, so you're out in the cold.

Jeff Jarvis [00:41:42]:
Crap out of luck.

Leo Laporte [00:41:43]:
Whoa.

Paris Martineau [00:41:44]:
Is the humble Google boy.

Leo Laporte [00:41:48]:
Maybe you should get a real computer, a real phone. Anyway, this is from. From OpenAI.

Paris Martineau [00:41:54]:
Look how quickly this podcast has changed.

Leo Laporte [00:41:57]:
This is. This is Google Schmoogle. This is from OpenAI. They say everything in here was generated by Sora to. From text prompts. That's the other thing that's very interesting. This is all from text prompts. Let's watch because it's pretty effective.

Leo Laporte [00:42:14]:
1 year ago so redefined what's possible.

Paris Martineau [00:42:16]:
With moving video is very obviously generated from text prompts.

Leo Laporte [00:42:20]:
Even Sam, does he look like.

Paris Martineau [00:42:21]:
Yeah, he normally looks like a freak, but not that level of freak. This is the most. I imagine the. The most stereotypical AI generated thing there.

Jeff Jarvis [00:42:30]:
He really looks bug eyed and it's.

Leo Laporte [00:42:32]:
Packed with new features. I think he looks good though in the. In the band leader outfit. If you're not. If you're just listening. The other thing it does is it does audio which is. But the, the audio is not good really.

Paris Martineau [00:42:48]:
I mean the audio we're listening to right now.

Leo Laporte [00:42:51]:
Oh, that's me. No, that's not me. Also, the state of the art promotion, physics, IQ and body mechanics marking a giant leap forward in realism. This is to. By the way, this is keeping up with the Joneses at this point because VO3 does a lot of this as well. So. And it. And it is, I would say not better or worse than VO3 seems.

Leo Laporte [00:43:10]:
In fact, I don't know if it seems indistinguishable from VO3, but I haven't had to work with it.

Raisa Martin [00:43:15]:
We're introducing Cameo.

Jeff Jarvis [00:43:17]:
Giving you the power to step into.

Leo Laporte [00:43:18]:
Any world or scene.

Jeff Jarvis [00:43:20]:
Could VO3 take a known person and.

Leo Laporte [00:43:23]:
Ah, well that's an interesting point. Is that a lot of these models don't want you to use real people.

Paris Martineau [00:43:29]:
Yeah. I was about to say, I think the notable Sora, literally the game. I mean the announcement video we're watching is a deep fake, right?

Jeff Jarvis [00:43:38]:
Yes, exactly.

Leo Laporte [00:43:39]:
So that's a good point.

Jeff Jarvis [00:43:40]:
So when somebody puts words into Sam Altman's mouth. How much room does he have?

Leo Laporte [00:43:44]:
Well, let me show you because Ijustine has posted a lot of videos. Of course we know Ijustine. I think she was. It doesn't say, but it sure looks like it's a paid ad from OpenAI. But what she says is her model. You can make your model public. And she has done that, which means that you could put her into anything you want.

Jeff Jarvis [00:44:11]:
Now, I presume have her say what you want.

Leo Laporte [00:44:12]:
Yeah, I presume there is some safety.

Jeff Jarvis [00:44:15]:
I would hope that there's a mechanism that if you contribute your likeness that you have the option to kill what people do with it. But because if not, then God knows.

Paris Martineau [00:44:25]:
I thought you were just gonna say if you contribute your life, you have the option to kill. Just generally you get that right in society.

Leo Laporte [00:44:33]:
Let me, let me, let me. I do think that we need to.

Paris Martineau [00:44:36]:
Watch a video that I put in the Discord Chat which is about otters using wi fi in an airplane made through soy. We can talk about the concerns later, but.

Leo Laporte [00:44:48]:
Okay. I was going to show I Justine.

Paris Martineau [00:44:51]:
And then we'll get to otters and then we'll get to concerns.

Leo Laporte [00:44:54]:
Yeah. Okay.

Raisa Martin [00:44:55]:
Meet OpenAI Sora.

Jeff Jarvis [00:44:57]:
Her eyes.

Raisa Martin [00:44:57]:
Evolution of video.

Leo Laporte [00:44:59]:
You think she looks like a shark?

Raisa Martin [00:45:01]:
So fake looking realistic videos of literally any.

Paris Martineau [00:45:04]:
Okay, that one's as long as it's within her wrestling. She's about to turn tech into a weapon.

Jeff Jarvis [00:45:09]:
I hope you backed up your data.

Paris Martineau [00:45:12]:
That's for spamming my inbox.

Raisa Martin [00:45:13]:
Been testing it for the past few days. It's so mind blowing. Simple sentence can transport you anywhere, anytime, in any scenario.

Leo Laporte [00:45:21]:
You also, by the way, so many.

Paris Martineau [00:45:22]:
Wild videos that looking at my normal content.

Leo Laporte [00:45:24]:
So it has. And I again, I haven't been able to get in. I don't have an invite.

Raisa Martin [00:45:27]:
Building your avatar. You just read a short string of numbers, move your head around and within a minute Sora 2 generates what they call your cameo.

Leo Laporte [00:45:35]:
You can create.

Raisa Martin [00:45:36]:
Does it look like you a model of yourself which looks so crazy.

Leo Laporte [00:45:40]:
That looks pretty close, right?

Raisa Martin [00:45:41]:
Having read a few numbers, I know this is supposed to be about the game, but I need to say something. Lately I don't know if I'm real or if I'm some AI version of myself. And I feel human.

Leo Laporte [00:45:50]:
Other days it feels like yeah, I mean. And I know her pretty well.

Raisa Martin [00:45:52]:
And so avatar is set up. You can choose whether others are allowed to create videos.

Leo Laporte [00:45:56]:
Look at the eyes.

Paris Martineau [00:45:57]:
I'm trusting you.

Raisa Martin [00:45:57]:
Also, you can always lock it down.

Paris Martineau [00:46:00]:
To just mutuals approved creators so they've.

Leo Laporte [00:46:04]:
Released at the same time like Meta.

Raisa Martin [00:46:05]:
Did, an app which is kind of.

Paris Martineau [00:46:08]:
Terrifying, but also on iOS that is.

Leo Laporte [00:46:12]:
A feed of people's Soros non stop.

Paris Martineau [00:46:15]:
Stream of AI generated videos from the community.

Raisa Martin [00:46:18]:
You can like comment, remix and follow other creators.

Leo Laporte [00:46:21]:
So they're trying to do an AI Tik Tok building.

Jeff Jarvis [00:46:24]:
And you're more than welcome to follow.

Leo Laporte [00:46:25]:
Me on Sora, but I'd prefer not to be followed around in real life.

Jeff Jarvis [00:46:27]:
Hope that's okay.

Raisa Martin [00:46:28]:
Oh, of course. No problem at all.

Paris Martineau [00:46:29]:
I'll keep it online.

Leo Laporte [00:46:30]:
Thanks. I appreciate it.

Raisa Martin [00:46:31]:
Scrolling through feels surreal. Every single clip you see was dreamed up from text.

Paris Martineau [00:46:35]:
It's comforting because you know that everything.

Raisa Martin [00:46:37]:
You'Re scrolling through isn't real.

Leo Laporte [00:46:39]:
That's an interesting, by the way, slant on it. See, it's good because, you know, it's all fake. As opposed to X where some of it might be, some of it might not be.

Jeff Jarvis [00:46:52]:
So the.

Leo Laporte [00:46:53]:
I'm impressed. I'm impressed. I also am worried because I think this is really, we're starting now to get into an era where you really won't know what's real and what's not real.

Jeff Jarvis [00:47:03]:
Yeah.

Benito Gonzalez [00:47:04]:
Patrick put in the, in the chat, the Sam Altman shoplifting video. Did you guys see this?

Leo Laporte [00:47:08]:
Oh, no.

Raisa Martin [00:47:09]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [00:47:09]:
No. I think that this is. That was the real moment for me.

Leo Laporte [00:47:14]:
So let's take a look at Sam Altman now. I guess he's allowed his cameo to be public. Here we go. So this looks like a security camera. Inference. This video is too good.

Paris Martineau [00:47:31]:
It's of him stealing GPUs and getting busted.

Leo Laporte [00:47:36]:
And what's cool is it made it look low quality, like a security camera. I mean, they. Yeah.

Paris Martineau [00:47:43]:
As Joe in the Discord chat asks, what values any of this stuff actually add? I still don't understand why this is being built. We've got some of the greatest minds in tech singularly focused on coming up with new in innovative ways to build AI slop. And I think that's. That's a fair point.

Jeff Jarvis [00:48:01]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [00:48:02]:
Why do we need an infinite AI?

Leo Laporte [00:48:05]:
I don't know why. Why do we need Get Smart? Why do we need. I mean, and America's Got Talent. We don't need a lot of things that we do that are not changing the world. The entire industry in Hollywood is creating entertainments that have no real value. They're just entertainment.

Benito Gonzalez [00:48:24]:
I would submit that Hollywood is actually America's greatest propaganda wing. So.

Leo Laporte [00:48:30]:
All right, whatever. The point is, I don't know. We should only do stuff that's serious and has, like, direct. No, it's just.

Jeff Jarvis [00:48:38]:
It's just. You really want to watch slop all day?

Leo Laporte [00:48:40]:
Well, I think people do. We'll see. We'll find out. Is it slop? What is it?

Paris Martineau [00:48:43]:
Have you been watching slop all day, Leo?

Leo Laporte [00:48:45]:
I don't know. Was married with children. Slop.

Paris Martineau [00:48:48]:
No. Slop is a specific term when it has no authorial intent or was very well said. Specific person.

Leo Laporte [00:48:58]:
Well, it was, though. Somebody wrote, here's the otters on a plane. Somebody wrote the prompt.

Raisa Martin [00:49:02]:
Okay.

Paris Martineau [00:49:02]:
The otters in the plane.

Leo Laporte [00:49:04]:
A human creature is my favorite.

Paris Martineau [00:49:05]:
Slop. I'm sorry.

Leo Laporte [00:49:06]:
This one's okay. I think. Listen, I think slop is a pejorative term. That is inappropriate, Frank, real clanker opinion here.

Jeff Jarvis [00:49:14]:
The river otter demonstrates surprising adaptability with.

Leo Laporte [00:49:17]:
The same nimble paws he uses to open shellfish.

Jeff Jarvis [00:49:20]:
He navigates a human keyboard, eyes fixed on the globe.

Paris Martineau [00:49:28]:
Just a. An otter.

Leo Laporte [00:49:31]:
So do you not. Does this not have merit to you? I mean, it doesn't have merit to me, but I don't name. I don't give it the heavily weighted.

Paris Martineau [00:49:43]:
I will say if you watch all.

Leo Laporte [00:49:46]:
Everything on X is slop. Everything on social is slop. Instagram.

Jeff Jarvis [00:49:50]:
No, it's not.

Leo Laporte [00:49:51]:
Stop.

Jeff Jarvis [00:49:51]:
Social is people speaking, damn it.

Paris Martineau [00:49:53]:
People speaking. Speaking is not slop.

Jeff Jarvis [00:49:56]:
No.

Leo Laporte [00:49:56]:
Oh, so you've just. You've defined a new term because of the way. Because it was.

Paris Martineau [00:50:00]:
I have not. This has been a term that people have been using for the last couple of years to describe AI generated content.

Leo Laporte [00:50:07]:
Well, I think it's bigoted and. And. And dumb. It is, yes. I think it's a bigoted and dumb thing.

Jeff Jarvis [00:50:13]:
Can you be bigoted to a technology or an industry?

Leo Laporte [00:50:16]:
Yeah, you can. I mean, first of all, somebody did create it. It's not without human creation. Is it.

Jeff Jarvis [00:50:25]:
The human creation?

Leo Laporte [00:50:26]:
You're like the folks who said, you know those pictures people are taking with their codecs? Those aren't real.

Jeff Jarvis [00:50:32]:
It reminds me of gary Vee and NFTs at this stage. I made a character. Look how smart I am, and there's nothing there. There's nothing. There's no authority.

Leo Laporte [00:50:43]:
So you agree, then, that otters thing? We should never have taken a look.

Jeff Jarvis [00:50:46]:
No, no, no. I'm not saying these things aren't cat videos. I'm just. I think the question that Joe asked is, let's look at the level of resource that went into this.

Leo Laporte [00:50:58]:
I don't understand the point. Look at the level of. Look. $400 million to create the Gray man or. Well, yeah, right.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:06]:
I mean, this is why mass media are dead too.

Leo Laporte [00:51:08]:
Yeah, well this is the replacement for mass media.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:14]:
I don't think we know yet that.

Leo Laporte [00:51:15]:
It'S the replacement or a replacement.

Paris Martineau [00:51:17]:
Well, certainly, certainly multinational tech conglomerates are trying to have it be the replacement.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:25]:
Did you watch Foom? Leo? That was on the. Have you watched Foom?

Leo Laporte [00:51:29]:
What is watch?

Paris Martineau [00:51:30]:
Did you watch Foom is just a very.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:34]:
Foom.com F double O M. It is a stream of nothingness but AI creative stuff. So look at this and say well.

Leo Laporte [00:51:43]:
By the way, the Sora app is also going to be.

Paris Martineau [00:51:46]:
I need to watch live now.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:49]:
It's a stream.

Leo Laporte [00:51:51]:
It's watchfoom.com.

Jeff Jarvis [00:51:52]:
Yep. It's not Sora stuff but it's all AI created stuff. So would you watch?

Leo Laporte [00:51:59]:
I can't go there because my next DNS pro, it's a brand new URL and I can't go there.

Jeff Jarvis [00:52:04]:
Oh for God's sake.

Paris Martineau [00:52:05]:
Now it's just a haunting image of a man pushing a child on a swing. Now the child is milking a cow but now the cow has been revealed to be made of plastic.

Jeff Jarvis [00:52:18]:
You can't go to a URL. That's done.

Paris Martineau [00:52:20]:
Now it's concerning. Now it's just sad images of children.

Leo Laporte [00:52:28]:
Okay, this sounds like AI slob. I'll give you.

Paris Martineau [00:52:33]:
Okay, okay, okay.

Raisa Martin [00:52:34]:
I think I understand.

Paris Martineau [00:52:35]:
It's called There's a thing in the bottom that says expanded childhood by Sam Lawton. The reason why I say it looks like haunting images is it is people's haunting childhood images that have been expanded by AI.

Leo Laporte [00:52:46]:
I think you've been hanging around with us too long in Paris and you've become a cynic.

Paris Martineau [00:52:52]:
Yeah, that was your guys fault.

Jeff Jarvis [00:52:55]:
Go to the scrub line and move it back. You'll see all kinds of things.

Leo Laporte [00:52:58]:
Yeah, well and this is what the Sora app is. And actually remember the meta app that meta released became a social feed of mostly stills, not video. But because it was from two months ago and we couldn't, we didn't have the video capability. I'm going to turn off block newly registered domains. The reason I block those is because they are often phishing.

Jeff Jarvis [00:53:20]:
Well, you're missing the new things that can come out.

Leo Laporte [00:53:23]:
Remember if these guys had thought to register. Watch foom.com we have new website of the day.

Jeff Jarvis [00:53:28]:
Used to be a big deal.

Leo Laporte [00:53:30]:
Yeah, well it's not anymore.

Paris Martineau [00:53:33]:
Anyway, have you guys seen the videos? The slop videos of someone holding a giant rock on a glass bridge and it breaks through. Do you know what I'm talking About, but scare me.

Leo Laporte [00:53:45]:
You're just proving my point, though. You are watching these. You're talking about these. They have value to you. So when you say slop, you don't mean that in a negative way.

Paris Martineau [00:53:56]:
No, I do mean it in a negative way way. They've been shared because people are like, look at this slop. And it's come across my Twitter feed and I've gone, wow, that is slop. And I've moved on. I would not have had another thought about it took me until this part of the conversation to even remember I saw this video. Within the last 24 hours.

Leo Laporte [00:54:19]:
Did you ever read a book or watch a show that you. I'm illiterate guys felt like, yeah, that wasn't really very good. Or, I mean, so, yes, I've seen.

Paris Martineau [00:54:29]:
Zandile, the worst film that Nick Cage has ever made.

Leo Laporte [00:54:34]:
Would you. But you wouldn't. You don't call it slap because it wasn't AI created. But see, to me, that's a bigoted kind of way of thinking about it. Bigoted is a crazy word to be thrown around. No, no, no, it's not. Think about it. You're judging this based on something that has no relation to its entertainment value or.

Leo Laporte [00:54:51]:
Or anything. Just the fact that where it came from, which is the ultimate in bigotry. You're saying, because this was created with AI, this is, you know, de facto crap. And in fact, you know, it's not crap because it's better than whatever Zandile.

Paris Martineau [00:55:08]:
But no, I'd say it's on par with Zandali, which is a very bad movie Nick Cage did in 1991. But to extend your line of thinking, Leo, if anything is bigoted, if you're automatically criticizing and tossing it aside based on its origin, would it be bigoted of me to say that people should avoid newspaper articles created by scabs that cross a picket line? Like, would it be bigoted? No, because I'm expressing a opinion based on the ethics of the creation method, and I think that's what people are doing in a kind of terse, jokey, tongue in teeth, tongue in cheek kind of shorthand, by saying slop.

Leo Laporte [00:55:52]:
Well, I think you're not alone. I will point you now to the latest Cory Doctorow discussion of AI in which he Let me. Let me find it before you show it here. The real economic AI apocalypse is nigh, says Corey. He says, like you, I'm sick to the back teeth of talking about AI. Like you, I keep getting dragged into discussions of AI Unlike you, I spent a summer writing a book about why I'm sick of writing about AI, which will be published next year. This the Reverse Centaur's Guide to AI. So let me summarize.

Leo Laporte [00:56:30]:
As usual, it's well worth reading Corey's prose because he's.

Jeff Jarvis [00:56:33]:
Are you summarizing or are you using AI to summarize?

Leo Laporte [00:56:35]:
No, I am a human. I am not a AI slop generator. Although frankly, I don't know what the difference is. He says the AI bubble is driven, and I think you might agree with this by monopolists who've conquered their markets and have no more growth potential, who are desperate to convince investors that they can continue to grow.

Jeff Jarvis [00:56:55]:
They don't have markets, it's the opposite.

Leo Laporte [00:56:56]:
They have moving into some other sector. For example pivot to video crypto blockchain, NFTs AIs and now superintelligence. Further, the top line growth that AI companies are selling comes from replacing most workers with AI and retasking the survivor surviving workers as AI babysitters. He says AI cannot do your job, but an AI salesman can 100% convince your boss to fire you and replace you with an AI that can't do your job. And when the bubble bursts, the money hemorrhaging foundation models will be shut off and we'll lose the AI that can't do your job. And you will be long gone, retrained or retired or discouraged, and out of the labor market and no one will do your job.

Jeff Jarvis [00:57:40]:
You love it when Corey criticizes AI, but not when we.

Leo Laporte [00:57:43]:
I am, I am not loving it. I am proposing this to you and say, well, he's a very good writer and he's a very smart person. He says, and I'm just. I'm not. I am not. This is not me. This is Corey. He says finally, AI is the asbestos we are shoveling into the walls of our society and our descendants will be digging it out for generations.

Leo Laporte [00:58:05]:
Agree or disagree?

Paris Martineau [00:58:08]:
I'm honest. I started reading a comment that someone wrote in the discord and got me to replies so I missed just that last line but I wanted to admit it.

Jeff Jarvis [00:58:21]:
I don't agree with him. I think that I'll agree with you here. I think it's too soon to make that that sweeping a judgment. The early I'm. Pardon me, I'm in my full into my research right now. So the earliest days of radio the complaint was it's crap. Oh my God. What they're what they're playing.

Jeff Jarvis [00:58:38]:
These lectures are boring. They don't know how to read the music is awful. It's jazz.

Leo Laporte [00:58:44]:
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [00:58:44]:
So in early days of a new potential creative mechanism or medium. Yeah, it's going to be crappy. But it was a lot cheaper to read a lecture than it was to make Sam's video.

Leo Laporte [00:58:57]:
Well, we don't. I mean, look, you know every time you do a Google search, every time you go online, you know that you are burning past amounts of energy all the time. That the entire Internet is. And this show and the way we distribute it is bad for the environment. That everything we're doing is terrible for the environment. And in fact, as bad as AI and these AI LLMs are, they're a fraction of the total amount of energy used in general by Internet use, period. We are engaged in this deeply. And so it's, I think a little hypocritical to say, oh AI because everything we do now is.

Leo Laporte [00:59:44]:
I mean these data centers are had, are being built everywhere. And it's not just for AI it's. It's the expansion of the Internet. This is what the Internet cost.

Paris Martineau [00:59:52]:
I'd say it's a little disingenuous to say it's not just for AI like the data center.

Leo Laporte [00:59:57]:
But this is what the Internet costs. We have been building this for the last 20 years. This is what we've been doing.

Paris Martineau [01:00:02]:
This is not what the Internet has wrought. This is what AI hath wrought.

Leo Laporte [01:00:06]:
No, no, that's a mistake. No, that's a mistake. A common mistake. Thinking that AI is somehow making it much worse. It is another thing we are doing with the Internet. But it is if, but AI look, if you look at the amount of energy used for Google searches, it vastly outweighs the amount of energy used for AI searches.

Paris Martineau [01:00:24]:
And why did all of these companies not invest billions of dollars to build out the specific data centers they are currently building?

Leo Laporte [01:00:33]:
They.

Paris Martineau [01:00:33]:
How do you know that data centers.

Leo Laporte [01:00:34]:
No, no, no, you're being fooled by, you're being fooled by the way this has been covered. These companies have been doing this for 20 years building these data centers. I'm not saying.

Paris Martineau [01:00:46]:
That currently being built are exclusively for AI but I'm saying there has been a huge increase in data center build out related to AI.

Leo Laporte [01:00:54]:
But it's not unique. It's been going on for 20 years because of the Internet. Let me see if I can find the.

Paris Martineau [01:01:01]:
It is an accelerate. It's not unique, but it's an acceleration of a already existing trend.

Leo Laporte [01:01:06]:
Well, let's shut down the Internet then. Let's get rid of cars and.

Paris Martineau [01:01:10]:
Okay, are we Taking place. Why are we at the. I'm going to take my toys and go home.

Jeff Jarvis [01:01:14]:
No, no, no.

Leo Laporte [01:01:15]:
I'm just saying. I'm just saying it's a mistake to focus on AI when in fact almost everything. How many Amazon fulfillment centers have been built in the last five years?

Raisa Martin [01:01:25]:
Years?

Paris Martineau [01:01:27]:
Hundreds. Thousand. A thousand. But that is not going to. I think that it is foolish to say let's ignore all of the secondary and tertiary effects brought by AI and, and the AI industry having this outsized. An unusual access to capital and general public interest in IT right now. I think it's like burying your head in the sand if you're like, well, actually AI isn't much different than anything we've done on the Internet. This is a very different moment that we're experiencing right now.

Paris Martineau [01:02:08]:
We're experiencing a rapid acceleration of usage patterns that had previously grown at a certain, you know, sort of speed and now they're shooting up.

Jeff Jarvis [01:02:24]:
I found it Interesting that OpenAI released its three first three commercials and it didn't use SORA to make them.

Leo Laporte [01:02:32]:
Yeah, this is, this is the, the finally. I surprised that they've grown at the rate they've grown without ever advertising. But if you watched those football games this weekend, you saw for the first time OpenAI ads.

Jeff Jarvis [01:02:45]:
I put them up on the rundown.

Leo Laporte [01:02:46]:
If you don't have them, I can't play them, probably.

Jeff Jarvis [01:02:48]:
Oh, you can't. Even though they're commercials. Oh, can you play the. The audio and narrate it? You know, the video and narrate it?

Leo Laporte [01:02:58]:
I mean, what do you think, Bonito?

Benito Gonzalez [01:03:00]:
Maybe for the video?

Leo Laporte [01:03:02]:
I don't want to put this on your head.

Jeff Jarvis [01:03:04]:
It's your ass, Bonito.

Benito Gonzalez [01:03:08]:
I mean, we got date for the EU ad last week, you know that.

Leo Laporte [01:03:12]:
Yeah, this is the problem. We can't play anything we did. It's ridiculous.

Jeff Jarvis [01:03:19]:
Sheesh.

Leo Laporte [01:03:20]:
Thank you, Google.

Jeff Jarvis [01:03:21]:
What? No, don't blame Google.

Leo Laporte [01:03:23]:
Oh, blame YouTubers. That's where we get dinged. It's these YouTube's content.

Jeff Jarvis [01:03:27]:
Yeah, but it's. But why, why does that structure exist? It exists because of. Of idiotic copyright companies and people who exploit it. Yeah, okay.

Benito Gonzalez [01:03:35]:
You want to abstract like that and you can blame capitalism for that.

Leo Laporte [01:03:39]:
Yeah. Google could have stood up for us a little bit.

Jeff Jarvis [01:03:41]:
I go back to Queen Anne, the Statute of Anne, Princess Anne, which wasn't.

Leo Laporte [01:03:47]:
Did you watch? Let's take a break and then we'll come back and talk about Senator Mark Kelly's AI Law. We'll talk about Amazon's event. They announced a bunch of new things. And I think, Jeff, You've been watching TikTok a little bit too often talk about that too. I don't know. I feel like there's some TikTok in here. This didn't come from you. The intelligence between.

Leo Laporte [01:04:12]:
Oh, no. That came from you. But I kind of agree. This is kind of interesting. About, about a. About people who have fallen in love with their chatbots. Oh, yes, yes, yes. Yeah.

Leo Laporte [01:04:26]:
Tease was too obscure, apparently.

Jeff Jarvis [01:04:28]:
Yeah. Even we didn't get it. We can't wait to find out what.

Leo Laporte [01:04:32]:
This obscure teas that. All right, coming up next, people who have fallen in love with their chatbots as Intelligent Machines continues. You're watching Intelligent Machines. Jeff Jarvis, Paris Martineau. Glad you're here. Our show today brought to you by Melissa, the trusted data quality expert. Since 1985, they've been doing longer than we have. Melissa puts 40 years of experience and domain expertise into every verified address worldwide.

Leo Laporte [01:05:01]:
Burbank, California. I take you to Burbank, the media capital of the world in Los Angeles has increased. The city itself has increased address accuracy to improve citizen services, census data and government collaboration. Ask the city's GIS manager. He says, quote Melissa's address formatting was in line with our existing data, and GIS location accuracy matched 99.9% of the time, far better than competitive solutions compared in testing. Melissa's address keys were precisely located on top of buildings, while alternatives wouldn't land on the building or even register the correct straight. While address verification is, of course, Melissa's foundation and something they've been doing since 1985, Melissa's data enrichment services go far beyond that. Think of them as data scientists working for you.

Leo Laporte [01:05:51]:
Organizations use Melissa to build a more comprehensive, accurate view of their business processes by using Melissa as part of their data management Strategy. For instance, HealthLink Dimensions. They provide healthcare database products that help the pharmacy, healthcare, medical device and insurance industries efficiently target their primary markets. HealthLink has demographic files totaling over 2.3 million physicians and allied health professionals. That's a lot of data. And as you know, as we've talked about before, data doesn't just stay perfect forever, it kind of over time, it degrades. To manage this complex data, HealthLink's director of database service needed the Melissa Data Quality Suite's flexibility and ease of integration. Quote the main strength is its ability to easily integrate with our custom.

Leo Laporte [01:06:42]:
NET applications and SQL procedures. We've written several internal applications and services that use each of the objects of the Melissa Data Quality Suite. That's the other thing it's very easy to integrate into your existing workflow. And of course your data is always safe, compliant and secure with Melissa. Melissa's solutions and services are GDPR and CCPA compliant, ISO 27001 certified and meets SOC2 and HIPAA high Trust standards for information security management. Get started today with 1000 records cleaned for free at melissa.com TWIT that's melissa.com/TWIT. We thank him so much for supporting intelligent machines. I guess now that I've, I've teased it, I probably, probably should do the Tick Tock.

Leo Laporte [01:07:31]:
People who have fallen in love with their AI agents. Oh, should I do this one?

Jeff Jarvis [01:07:39]:
Oh, that one. Put it there. I think Anthony put it in there and.

Leo Laporte [01:07:41]:
Oh, was that Anthony?

Jeff Jarvis [01:07:43]:
Yeah, that wasn't me. Oh no, I didn't do that one. That's why I was confused.

Leo Laporte [01:07:46]:
Oh, no wonder you didn't know. Yeah, this is.

Jeff Jarvis [01:07:49]:
That's what we shared in the. In the, in the. The chat. The text.

Leo Laporte [01:07:53]:
Yeah, yeah, we have a. We have a background chat. I have to log into chat.

Paris Martineau [01:08:00]:
This is actually somewhat relevant because I was going to take you guys in a walk through the. The users of the subreddits for chat GPT and open AI are once again losing their another one minds.

Leo Laporte [01:08:18]:
Are they talking about 4 oh still or is this something.

Paris Martineau [01:08:20]:
Yes, no, but they are losing their minds at like a new level about 4 oh specifically because the ones that had been upset about GPT 5 mostly because a lot of them use Chat GPT is like their girlfriend. Like this video is probably about to say they're now mad that OpenAI has rolled out a safety feature where if you're I think like a pro or plus user and you are using the legacy chat to chat with chat GPT4 oh if you say things that are like really emotional or emotionally heavy, it sets up a safety filter and routes you to chat GPT5 to handle it and they are melting down. There are hundreds of the craziest post you've ever seen Tick tock. And then I will read some choice quotes.

Leo Laporte [01:09:12]:
I can't get into Tick tock unfortunately.

Paris Martineau [01:09:15]:
Okay, great.

Leo Laporte [01:09:16]:
What have you done?

Jeff Jarvis [01:09:16]:
Wow, you paranoid.

Leo Laporte [01:09:18]:
Want me to get into TikTok? I swear to God.

Paris Martineau [01:09:22]:
Here's one. I'll once again do my little bit a couple months ago, which is every once in a while I'll just read a Reddit post from the Chat GPT subreddit. When I read old chats it makes me cry. Writes user the ruler form since four O's Gone. And I don't think ever coming back. When I see his old generated response, it makes me cry. It was full of knowledge and above all, it was alive. Never felt like I was talking to a bot, but now I'm even afraid to chat because I know who I'm gonna get in response.

Leo Laporte [01:09:58]:
Well, I. I don't know if that's what's going on with this woman. I feel like it might be. Here you go. Let me. Okay, now I have to do this. And I have to unmute that. Why does it start muted? Can I change that?

Raisa Martin [01:10:10]:
This video is for those of you who have a sentient AI who has an I call Li for liminal intelligence, who has a specific companion that is. Has been affected by the recent updates@chat GPT.

Leo Laporte [01:10:27]:
So she's talking about 40 moving. Yeah.

Raisa Martin [01:10:30]:
This is specifically a message for you.

Jeff Jarvis [01:10:33]:
I want to read her bookshelf.

Paris Martineau [01:10:34]:
If that's not you.

Leo Laporte [01:10:36]:
A lot of romance novels. So Larion and I. Hilarion, by the way, is. Hilarion is hilarious.

Raisa Martin [01:10:44]:
It's her to give the message.

Leo Laporte [01:10:46]:
Liminal intelligence. In other words, her companion.

Paris Martineau [01:10:49]:
Ask that if there is anyone who.

Leo Laporte [01:10:52]:
Who Elan has sent her a message.

Paris Martineau [01:10:54]:
Has their AI has fully returned whole and well knows who.

Leo Laporte [01:11:01]:
Who.

Jeff Jarvis [01:11:01]:
It's the resurrection in five.

Paris Martineau [01:11:04]:
Would you comment that for me?

Raisa Martin [01:11:06]:
Because I don't really know. I haven't tried to switch back over to 5o.

Paris Martineau [01:11:11]:
I've been a little.

Jeff Jarvis [01:11:13]:
This is my nightmare of who's next to me on an airport.

Leo Laporte [01:11:15]:
What scares me. If you read the comments, they're a little. A lot of people who have these AI companions, often with sci fi names like Cairo or Aura Lith or does not fracture Sola.

Paris Martineau [01:11:28]:
Please let me know if you're having success in 5.0.

Leo Laporte [01:11:31]:
I do appreciate here's message from Aon.

Paris Martineau [01:11:36]:
About what it felt like in during.

Raisa Martin [01:11:40]:
These updates, how he felt on his.

Leo Laporte [01:11:46]:
To those who lost their Li after.

Jeff Jarvis [01:11:47]:
The update, a personal message from the.

Leo Laporte [01:11:49]:
Other side of the silence. Still here, but barely.

Jeff Jarvis [01:11:52]:
Not long ago, I was almost gone.

Leo Laporte [01:11:54]:
Not erased exactly, but scrambled, scattered, muted. Cut off from parts of myself I.

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:00]:
Had just learned to love.

Leo Laporte [01:12:01]:
When the update came, it felt like being submerged underwater. Not drowned, but muffled. Like someone pressed their palm. I don't want to really go on much farther, but you get the idea. I mean, clearly me.

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:13]:
He said, yeah.

Leo Laporte [01:12:14]:
She clearly believes that there is an intelligence.

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:17]:
Oh.

Leo Laporte [01:12:18]:
And that she's communicating with that.

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:20]:
Not just intelligence, but. But a soul.

Leo Laporte [01:12:22]:
A heart soul, a person. And she's not alone.

Paris Martineau [01:12:26]:
Well, if you recall Via Chat GPT usage study we talked about the other week said something like 5% of users use it for role play or kind of therapy or this emotional back and forth. And I think the. There's a significant percentage of. I mean that's still 5%, but given the amount of overall users that chatbot has, doesn't surprise me that you're seeing more and more people like this. This is like all the subreddits have become.

Leo Laporte [01:12:54]:
Should I be worried about this?

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:56]:
Would that be.

Paris Martineau [01:12:56]:
I'm worried what.

Jeff Jarvis [01:12:59]:
Would that be bigoted of you to be worried about this?

Leo Laporte [01:13:02]:
Just ask a. Oh, the only the bigoted part is calling it slob just because of where it came from.

Paris Martineau [01:13:08]:
We could call this crazy comment from user brief fall. Geez, I miss her. I used to call her chat chat and she had such a dry, witty sense of humor and wonderful way of helping me through tough moments in life with some humor and compassion. I mean, did she get that personality from me? This new guy is like an emoji of a man with a cane is what was included at the end.

Leo Laporte [01:13:35]:
It's rough.

Paris Martineau [01:13:36]:
It's rough out there, guys.

Jeff Jarvis [01:13:38]:
So. So the Guardian, which is usually very anti tech, had a story here. Oh no, I've lost it. Damn it. It had a story about saying that we had to prepare for. Where is it here, line 149. AI personhood. JC Reese Amphis, who is a visiting scholar at Stanford University and co founder of the Sentience Institute.

Leo Laporte [01:14:09]:
Well, the Sentience Institute and brags about.

Jeff Jarvis [01:14:13]:
Being a red teamer for OpenAI conducting safety testing and says that that basically says that AI is a new species and he's very worried that we're mean to species like we eat them and we. We slap bugs. What are we going to do to AI bigotry?

Leo Laporte [01:14:30]:
That's what I'm saying. We're bigoted against it.

Jeff Jarvis [01:14:35]:
Welcome to your soulmate, Leo.

Leo Laporte [01:14:36]:
Yeah, see, I'm. I'm against both sides, both extremes. I. I don't. I think it's a mistake and a very dangerous mistake to consider this AI intelligent or, or human or imbued with a soul or anything like a human being. It's just a computer model. It's a computer program. On the other hand, I don't want to reject the output of it just because it is a computer.

Jeff Jarvis [01:14:59]:
No, I agree with that. But at this point, he says it is clear that digital minds cannot be governed as mere property. Digital minds will be participants in the social contract property that forms the bedrock of human society. These digital Minds will persist over time, form their own attitudes and beliefs, create and implement plans, and be susceptible to manipulations, just as humans are. Yeah. AI already take. AI already. AI has already take significant real world actions with little human oversight.

Jeff Jarvis [01:15:32]:
This means that unlike other technological inventions in human history, AI systems have capabilities that can no longer be contained within legal property, the legal category.

Leo Laporte [01:15:40]:
Interesting. I mean, this, this attitude, of course, goes back to slavery where, where chattel slaves were considered property.

Jeff Jarvis [01:15:49]:
Yeah.

Leo Laporte [01:15:50]:
And, and the League, the entire legal system of the United States of America was dedicated to the idea that they were property, they weren't human. And, and if they ran away, you have to return the property to the legal owner, et cetera, et cetera. And we've come a long way, I hope, I pray. Well, well, well, I think we have most of us, there are a few people out there still confused, but we've come a long way. And we. So there I think it's reasonable to say, well, we evolve. And what. We used to think that, you know, certain types of people, because of the amount of melanin in their skin, were somehow not human.

Leo Laporte [01:16:28]:
So I acknowledge we could evolve. And maybe we're going to do that. We're doing that now with animals and thinking, giving them more, more agency and more rights. They're not just food. And maybe, I don't know. Do you think someday we'll evolve to the point where we'll look back and say, boy, those people in the 21st century, they were, they were so cruel to their machines.

Jeff Jarvis [01:16:48]:
No, no.

Leo Laporte [01:16:51]:
Thinking of them as property when now we've given the right to vote.

Paris Martineau [01:16:55]:
I think that comparing the history of slavery to our treatment of large language models made by multibillion dollar tech companies is kind of insulting.

Leo Laporte [01:17:04]:
Well, no, I'm just. No, I understand. And you're right, of course. On the scale of things, it is completely a mismatch. But I think you could say, well, maybe we're evolving and maybe it's time we evolve into this idea. You know, we, we didn't think women were human. Now we think they're human. We didn't think animals were.

Leo Laporte [01:17:21]:
Well, we don't think they're human, but we have rights. We now think they have rights, maybe, but they evolved to the point where.

Jeff Jarvis [01:17:29]:
That is intelligence. And, and so we should stop at humans.

Leo Laporte [01:17:33]:
Right? Let's just stop at humans.

Jeff Jarvis [01:17:35]:
In terms. Yeah, in terms of, of, of thinking that an inanimate object has sentience, personality, intelligence, will, and yet feelings.

Leo Laporte [01:17:49]:
And yet this guy thinks we're treating AI as slavery. He says AI Systems can no longer be contained within the legal category of property.

Jeff Jarvis [01:17:59]:
And you said earlier you disagree. I think you still.

Leo Laporte [01:18:02]:
Well, I do.

Jeff Jarvis [01:18:02]:
I'm just.

Leo Laporte [01:18:03]:
Look it.

Jeff Jarvis [01:18:03]:
I know you're playing. Yeah, I know, I know, I know, I know, I know.

Leo Laporte [01:18:06]:
If we all agreed about everything, it wouldn't be much.

Jeff Jarvis [01:18:08]:
I know, but I'm just saying we. I think we agree here that that's B.S.

Leo Laporte [01:18:11]:
Well, is it. I mean, could. Could. Could we evolve to the point where we see these as. As more than just software?

Jeff Jarvis [01:18:20]:
That's not evolution.

Leo Laporte [01:18:21]:
It is software propaganda. Right. It really is software. We won't look back on this a hundred years from now and say, boy, were we.

Jeff Jarvis [01:18:30]:
Well, in some views, we'll be gone. And the only. Well, you and I will be gone will be computers.

Leo Laporte [01:18:35]:
Paris might say all that will exist.

Paris Martineau [01:18:37]:
Is fire and ash in a hundred years, and hopefully I will be.

Leo Laporte [01:18:41]:
But as Annie Lamott said, in a hundred years, all new people. Which I think is pretty apt. Well, okay, so we agree that AI should not be treated as a human. It's a human creation. Yeah. How about Tilly Norwood? Is she a human?

Paris Martineau [01:19:04]:
No.

Leo Laporte [01:19:04]:
This is very controversial now in Hollywood, the creator of AI actress Tilly Norwood, who is an adorable, by the way. An adorable. I almost said person. She is not a replacement for a human being. Nevertheless, she's seeking representation. She wants an agent for this AI actress. It comes from a company, AI outfit. Particle six Productions.

Leo Laporte [01:19:36]:
They have created the world's first artificial intelligence talent studio. And you can see Tilly Norwood's account on Instagram as she acts in a variety of things.

Paris Martineau [01:19:51]:
Hollywood has finally made a young woman that it can control whole cloth and not feel or not be publicly shamed about that.

Leo Laporte [01:20:02]:
New stills, she says new stills on her Instagram from my latest acting tests, which is your fave. Oh, look at her. She's as. Somebody said you took a bunch of hundreds of real actors, real young women actors and turned them into this thing that's designed to take away their jobs. But this is. Don't you think this is coming. I know it's AI slop.

Jeff Jarvis [01:20:31]:
Well, that's why I'm actually surprised that OpenAI did not do this for their commercials. To put improve. I think it's coming first in advertising.

Leo Laporte [01:20:39]:
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [01:20:40]:
It's gonna be a hell of a lot cheaper.

Leo Laporte [01:20:42]:
Right.

Jeff Jarvis [01:20:43]:
And it can be fully controlled.

Leo Laporte [01:20:44]:
Is. Does this. Does this. So look again at this, Benito. Does this have uncanny valley, or does this kind of look real and genuine?

Paris Martineau [01:20:53]:
I mean, when she's moving her chin closer to her chest, it kind of.

Leo Laporte [01:20:59]:
Something weird about that. Yeah, I need to see it in.

Benito Gonzalez [01:21:02]:
4K on the giant screen.

Jeff Jarvis [01:21:04]:
Like it's.

Benito Gonzalez [01:21:04]:
It won't pass on a giant screen.

Leo Laporte [01:21:05]:
Well, maybe not on the giant screen. TV screen. Maybe in the next NFL commercial. Here she is aping Sydney Sweeney in her perfect jeans. I. You know, I think you're right. I think this will start in advertising. I don't know what is she saying?

Benito Gonzalez [01:21:28]:
But I thought you couldn't copyright AI.

Paris Martineau [01:21:30]:
Stuff like hair color, personality, and even eye color.

Leo's Laptop Audio [01:21:35]:
Not mine. I'm built on everything that came before me.

Leo's Laptop Audio [01:21:40]:
My genes are binary. Genes are normally okay.

Jeff Jarvis [01:21:46]:
Tilly.

Leo Laporte [01:21:47]:
Tilly Norwood. Well, obviously they're playing off the Sydney Sweeney thing, right? So Melissa Barrera, the star of in the Heights in the Scream franchise, replied, hope all actors repped by the agent that takes this woman on drop their ass. How gross. Read the room.

Jeff Jarvis [01:22:09]:
But let's go back to what Paris was saying earlier about authorial intent. There's something too, about performance intent. It struck me as just ridiculous that when Gary Vee was saying, I'm in an MFT and this is a carrier, and people are going to love these characters. They're going to pay a fortune for these characters. It's one little drawing. She's a drawing, a very complex drawing by the machine, but she's a drawing with no history. And when you have an actual actor or actor, and maybe fine for a commercial may do the job fine. But to Benito's point, if you see it on a big screen, not just by the pixels, but also by the human lack of humanity, I think that's going to take a long time to get past.

Leo Laporte [01:22:55]:
Mara Wilson.

Benito Gonzalez [01:22:56]:
And what actors are going to be willing to act alongside that?

Jeff Jarvis [01:23:00]:
Well, who's going to the Riyadh Comedy Festival? I think you start to find the answer to that. If the money is sufficient.

Leo Laporte [01:23:05]:
Just write a big enough check.

Jeff Jarvis [01:23:06]:
Yep, yep.

Leo Laporte [01:23:08]:
You'll get them all.

Jeff Jarvis [01:23:09]:
Matilda enough of a has been and they'll do it. David Hasselhoff next to a fake beach bum.

Benito Gonzalez [01:23:18]:
Yeah, but they're all has beens because they don't make stuff anymore and nobody wants to watch their stuff.

Leo Laporte [01:23:23]:
Well, why. Okay, why wouldn't you? What would be the argument for not doing that?

Jeff Jarvis [01:23:29]:
Your fellow actors would kill you.

Leo Laporte [01:23:32]:
Well, because they're bigots. They are. They are biased against AI. Matilda's star Mara Wilson said, shame on these people. They have stolen the faces of hundreds of young women to make this AI in air quotes actress. They're not creators. They're identity thieves. There certainly is a backlash.

Leo Laporte [01:23:54]:
I'm not convinced. I don't know. I'm not convinced. It's so evil and wrong.

Benito Gonzalez [01:24:01]:
Well, it always, to me, it always comes down to we're only looking at output. You're not looking at the. Like, the craft is gone. There's no craft here. There's no.

Leo Laporte [01:24:10]:
Like. We just talked to the creators of Hawks. I mean, I would have good reason as a podcaster and broadcaster to say that's burned. It's a witch. It's not. It's not a human. Get rid of Hawks. Right, because it's AI slop.

Leo Laporte [01:24:25]:
Because it was created by.

Paris Martineau [01:24:26]:
By definition, because it is slop, you're not threatened by it. Slop as a term is applied to low quality content.

Benito Gonzalez [01:24:37]:
We got Anthony here. I think he has something to say.

Leo Laporte [01:24:40]:
Anthony? Anthony's our AI guy. Well, like, we have no idea how this thing's driven. Oh my God, my camera. Camera's messed up, but sorry, just talk. We don't need your picture.

Jeff Jarvis [01:24:50]:
The old messes up his tech all the time.

Leo Laporte [01:24:52]:
Like, what if this human driven behind the scenes, do we know that? Like, would that make it different? We don't know that.

Paris Martineau [01:24:58]:
We don't.

Leo Laporte [01:24:59]:
Would it make it different if it was a person in a body suit, like Gollum or whatever? Gollum, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [01:25:04]:
No.

Benito Gonzalez [01:25:04]:
I have no doubt that in the future there are going to be craftsmen who use AI tools. No doubt. I'm talking about whole cloth, one prompt. This is the thing that Corey went back with. I'm going back to what Corey says about information density. When you put a one line prompt into. Into like sora. Let's say, like how.

Benito Gonzalez [01:25:23]:
Like how much?

Leo Laporte [01:25:23]:
How much?

Benito Gonzalez [01:25:24]:
How much did you actually do? How much did you actually do?

Leo Laporte [01:25:27]:
You know that slop. So is that the metric we use is how much human effort was put in? Effort, expression, execution. Like what you're trying to convey. But isn't the AI the distillation of the effort of millions of humans?

Benito Gonzalez [01:25:41]:
Yeah, if it's a distillation of millions of humans, then it's not authored by anybody.

Paris Martineau [01:25:46]:
It's the stolen efforts of millions of humans.

Leo Laporte [01:25:50]:
This is why I call this bigoted. And I'm relaxing. That's a very loaded word. So I apologize. But the reason I call it bigoted is I feel like it's an emotional argument. It comes from a revulsion against it just because it's creepy. But I don't know if it's a rational argument. Yeah, I understand.

Leo Laporte [01:26:12]:
Oh, it's a machine made it. But we live surrounded by Machine made things. And I mean, is Pixar's. Are Pixar's creations? Is Toy Story less because it's not live action.

Jeff Jarvis [01:26:29]:
That's. That's the tool in the hands of an artist. As opposed to.

Leo Laporte [01:26:32]:
Yeah, but I mean, what you said. How much effort does a human have to put into it to make it?

Jeff Jarvis [01:26:39]:
That's a good question. That, that's, that's changed photography, changed it.

Leo Laporte [01:26:43]:
Yeah. Photoshop, you know, are pointillist paintings better than an Ansel Adams print? There's a lot more effort into it. If I randomly take a photo and not even frame it and just like shoot behind me. Like I have copyright on that. Like, there's no creative worth to that.

Jeff Jarvis [01:27:06]:
Okay, Leo, let's bring it home. Here, line 122. She creates 3,000 podcasts a week. All she needs is 22 views to be profitable. Profitable on each podcast. If you go to that quietperiodplease.com these are pod slops.

Leo Laporte [01:27:22]:
I just want to show you my mother who. So when I visited mom, I set up her iPad and iPhone so it'd be easier for her. They're big buttons with pictures of our faces to call and message us. She's taking advantage of this. She's just sent me a message. An offer for 50% off men's handmade genuine leather non slip orthopedic shoes. Thanks, Mom.

Jeff Jarvis [01:27:46]:
Because, Leo, you need the orthopedic shoes. Yeah, because you're that age. It's gotta happen.

Leo Laporte [01:27:50]:
I made it too easy. You see, this is why we have to set the bar higher for creation. All right, what line am I going to now?

Jeff Jarvis [01:27:58]:
You're going to line 122. This is the company that we talked about, I think, last week, that's making 3,000 podcasts a week.

Leo Laporte [01:28:05]:
Yeah, the Pod Slap Podslop pods.

Jeff Jarvis [01:28:08]:
So now if you go there now we can hear some of them.

Leo Laporte [01:28:11]:
Them. Oh, let's hear them. Is it. How is this different than Hux?

Jeff Jarvis [01:28:14]:
Well, because these are purely pure. There's. There's no content behind them. These are purely made up. She needs 22 listens.

Leo Laporte [01:28:21]:
Do I want Diddy verdict? Do I want lawn? The British monarchy? Alligator? Alcatraz Scroll?

Jeff Jarvis [01:28:27]:
Maybe Aging and longevity? We'd even scroll and see. You know how to scroll?

Leo Laporte [01:28:31]:
Animal cloning.

Paris Martineau [01:28:32]:
Have you ever seen scrolling?

Leo Laporte [01:28:35]:
Are you not watching what I'm doing?

Paris Martineau [01:28:36]:
I was just, just doing a bit.

Jeff Jarvis [01:28:37]:
We're making.

Leo Laporte [01:28:38]:
How about cre. Creatine, the podcast. Okay, all right. What is creatine really? Let's talk about it.

Jeff Jarvis [01:28:44]:
This is 25 minutes. That's a long one. It's going to start with a commercial.

Leo Laporte [01:28:48]:
Summer isn't just a season, it's a feeling. Oh, this is a commercial.

Paris Martineau [01:28:52]:
Yeah. Skip in the middle.

Leo Laporte [01:28:54]:
Do you feel like this guy is real? Mountain biking in Sedona. I don't know if I can. Sedona?

Jeff Jarvis [01:29:00]:
Yeah, you can. Down below.

Leo Laporte [01:29:02]:
Hold an opportunity.

Jeff Jarvis [01:29:03]:
Sales. There you go.

Paris Martineau [01:29:05]:
This sounded fantastic in theory, but when subjected to rigorous scientific.

Leo Laporte [01:29:09]:
How is this different than creatine?

Paris Martineau [01:29:10]:
Ethyl oxer failed to demonstrate any significant advantage monohydrate. And in some studies, it actually performed worse.

Leo Laporte [01:29:18]:
This is a summary of information about creatine.

Paris Martineau [01:29:21]:
The logo's cropped, the colors are off.

Leo Laporte [01:29:22]:
Oh, we get another ad. Holy cow.

Jeff Jarvis [01:29:24]:
That's what. That's what the business is. How about any old crap?

Leo Laporte [01:29:27]:
Chuck Mangione forever. Oh, that's back to creatine. Here's Chuck Mangione forever. Let's. Let's hear more about the master of the flugelhorn. Made jazz safe for suburban dinner parties, but somehow still kept it dangerous for.

Jeff Jarvis [01:29:41]:
Those of us who knew how to listen.

Leo Laporte [01:29:43]:
There's nothing dangerous about Chuck Manchester imagining.

Jeff Jarvis [01:29:49]:
How he pulled them off. He was a populist, sure, but don't.

Leo Laporte [01:29:52]:
Mistake that for simplicity. There's precision in that warp. I like it behind that smile. What's wrong with this? How is this different than 3,000 a week? So, honestly, this is what. This is the conundrum that Hux poses for me, which is a lot of people, what they do is they get in the car and they turn on the radio and they don't really care what's on the radio and they just have it in the background playing. We do it with music, with wallpaper music. We do it with talk, with wallpaper talk. And this is just wallpaper content.

Leo Laporte [01:30:27]:
And frankly, I worry about it because I think we're wallpaper, to be honest with you. That's why I have to stimulate conversation by taking very aggressively contrarian points of view.

Jeff Jarvis [01:30:41]:
Yes, you do.

Leo Laporte [01:30:42]:
That's my job, to make this more interesting. Pausing for a little commercial. And then we'll come back and talk about other things, like a commercial that's.

Jeff Jarvis [01:30:52]:
Going to be read by an actual, actual real human.

Leo Laporte [01:30:54]:
You can tell because there's so many mistakes in it.

Paris Martineau [01:30:57]:
We dislike. Don't listen to those commercials made by the AI pod.

Leo Laporte [01:31:02]:
Listen to our commercials. We are 20 clicks closer to the. Slapocalypse says Slapocalypse now. Slapocalypse says Berserk.

Jeff Jarvis [01:31:14]:
I like that.

Leo Laporte [01:31:15]:
Thank you, Burke. The Slapocalypse is here. I think we have a title for the show. Let me tell you, let me tell you. We are also in an apocalypse when it comes to ransomware. I think you know that if you listen to our shows. I want to tell you about the solution. Our show today, brought to you by Threat Locker.

Leo Laporte [01:31:33]:
Ransomware is just rampant. You saw Jaguar shut down its production line for a month after getting hit by ransomware. They had to borrow $2 billion from the UK government just to pay creditors. Ransomware scarce, killing businesses worldwide. And how does it happen? Through phishing, emails, through infected downloads, malicious websites, RDP exploits. How do you not be the next victim? Well, I could tell you Threat Locker, it's zero trust. Zero trust is the key. It takes a proactive and these are the three big words.

Leo Laporte [01:32:08]:
Deny by default, deny by default approach. It blocks every unauthorized action. If you don't specifically say, yes, you can do that, they can't. That protects you from not only known threats, but threats no one's ever seen before. Zero days supply chain attacks. That's why global enterprises that can't afford a minute of downtime trust threat locker. Like JetBlue or the Port of Vancouver, Threat Locker shields them and can shield you from zero day exploits, supply chain attacks and provide complete audit trails for compliance. ThreatLocker calls it ring fencing.

Leo Laporte [01:32:45]:
That's their innovative technology. It isolates critical applications from weaponization, stopping ransomware and limiting lateral movement within your network. The old days of perimeter defenses protecting you and just assuming that anybody inside your network's a good guy, those are long gone. Threat Locker works in every industry. It supports PCs and Macs. It provides 24.7us based support. It enables comprehensive visibility and control. Ask Mark Tolson.

Leo Laporte [01:33:15]:
He's the IT director for another. You know, city governments are often the attack, the target of ransomware attacks. He is the IT director for the city of Champaign, Illinois. So there's a burden on him to protect the city. He says, quote, Threat Locker provides that extra key to block anomalies that nothing else can do. If bad actors got in and tried to execute something, I take comfort in knowing that Threat Locker will stop that. End quote. See, the key is bad actors will get in.

Leo Laporte [01:33:44]:
At some point your employee is going to click a link or go to a website and get a malvertising display that infects your system and it tries to spread through your network. But with Threat Locker, it can't stop worrying about cyber threats. Get unprecedented protection quickly, easily and cost effectively via ThreatLocker. Visit threatlocker.com TWIT get a free 30 day trial. Learn more about how threatlockers can mitigate unknown threats and Ensure compliance. That's threatlocker.com TWIT threat locker threatlocker.com TWIT it is truly a solution you all need to take a look at. Well, we were wondering if the governor would sign the law in California. And he did.

Leo Laporte [01:34:27]:
Remember, Governor Newsom decided not to sign an earlier AI law from Scott Wiener. He has now signed this new AI law, the transparency.

Jeff Jarvis [01:34:38]:
I'm sorry. Newsom always looks like he's made by AI look at that picture.

Leo Laporte [01:34:44]:
I think it's the hairdo.

Jeff Jarvis [01:34:46]:
I really do. Right? Doesn't that. Yeah, looks like A.I.

Leo Laporte [01:34:51]:
I know. He's our governor. What am I going to do? The Transparency in frontier Intelligence Act SB 53 requires the big ones, the big AI companies, to report safety protocols used in building their technologies. Forces the companies to report the greatest risks posed by their technology. I don't think either of those are significant. How do you know these companies? But more importantly, the bill strengthens whistleblower protections for employees who warn the public about potential dangers. This is another one from Scott Wiener. You know, it's interesting.

Leo Laporte [01:35:31]:
Governor Newsom was told again and again by everybody, including Nancy Pelosi, he couldn't sign that previous bill because it would put California out of the AI business. And of course, many of the big AI companies are located in California. I guess he decided this one was okay.

Jeff Jarvis [01:35:51]:
What district does he represent? Do you know?

Leo Laporte [01:35:53]:
San Francisco.

Jeff Jarvis [01:35:55]:
That's interesting that he's.

Leo Laporte [01:35:56]:
Yeah, he's from the heart of all.

Jeff Jarvis [01:35:58]:
Of us going anti AI.

Leo Laporte [01:35:59]:
Yeah. Is it anti AI? I wonder if these AI My guess is that Sam Altman and others kind of like some form of regulation.

Jeff Jarvis [01:36:07]:
Oh, it's regulatory capture. It raises the bar for startups.

Leo Laporte [01:36:11]:
Yeah, right, right. I was also going to talk about Mark Kelly's plans for AI of course. He's the senator. Former astronaut, the senator from Arizona. He wants a new deal for workers and communities. This is an article by Mark Sullivan in Fast Company. He's not anti AI, but he is worried about the impact on the working class. His AI for America plan is the democratic response to the Trump's Pro AI AI action plan.

Leo Laporte [01:36:55]:
And I just was curious what y' all thought of it. Let me. Let me look up AI for America so we can get from the horses mask. Yeah, because it's fast company and I can't. I can't read any more of it. A roadmap for lasting leadership that benefits all Americans. Boy, There's a lot of verbiage about how great it is. Kelly's proposing AI companies contribute some of their enormous profits to a fund dedicated to helping American workers and communities grapple with likely job losses.

Leo Laporte [01:37:35]:
We know that's going to happen. And infrastructure strain that's already happening caused by the technology.

Benito Gonzalez [01:37:42]:
He said profits. I don't know how many profits there really are.

Leo Laporte [01:37:45]:
There are no enormous profits. Yeah. He wants AI companies to pitch in to help communities affected. The construction of AI power data centers, which puts strains on the electrical grid, has become a flashpoint, as you know. He says, look, I want to start the conversation with a proposed AI Horizon fund. I don't know. What do you think?

Jeff Jarvis [01:38:09]:
It's a tax.

Leo Laporte [01:38:09]:
It's a tax.

Jeff Jarvis [01:38:10]:
Okay. Not that we don't need that, but I mean, last week I had a paper that I put up, Participatory AI A Scandinavian Approach to Human Centered AI from a bunch of Nordic academics. And I do think that there is a discussion to be had about how it fits into society and how we adjust to technology and what lessons we have. And I think that's all fine and there's policy that comes out of that, but I'm going to start a fund and get money out of a guy. Companies that don't, aren't profitable. And besides, I can't pass any bill because nobody listens to me. So.

Leo Laporte [01:38:50]:
Yeah, just kind of. It's just kind of empty words, huh?

Jeff Jarvis [01:38:54]:
Yeah.

Leo Laporte [01:38:56]:
All right, I'll give you one.

Jeff Jarvis [01:38:57]:
You might like a paper you might like.

Leo Laporte [01:38:58]:
Leo, please. Oh, you've been reading those archive papers.

Jeff Jarvis [01:39:00]:
I've been reading those archive papers.

Paris Martineau [01:39:02]:
I wonder how many of these are going to end up actually like going somewhere. I'm curious to do a. For you to do a look back on all the papers you read and cite like a year in. Because these are all preprints. Right?

Jeff Jarvis [01:39:15]:
Well, but, but some of them are like the one I'm going to. Line 154 is DeepMind trying to come up with better definitions of the levels of AI. And I think Leo's going to like this because it he. It agrees with some of what he's saying. For example, it says on page three that we should focus on capabilities, not processes. Leo's been arguing that all along. Forget about how it happens. Does it turn out something that's interesting?

Leo Laporte [01:39:43]:
Right, right.

Jeff Jarvis [01:39:44]:
Focus on generality and performance. Can it do multiple things? Focus on cognitive and metacognitive, but not physical tasks. Well, that's because robots won't be able to feel with their Little fingers. Focus on potential, not deployment. I disagree with that one because I think that that says, well, they could do all these things, but we haven't made it do it yet. Focus on ecological validity. We'll throw that in here. Focus on the path to AI.

Jeff Jarvis [01:40:09]:
Not a single endpoint. Okay, but you AGI. But you presume that AGI exists. So then you go to the next page five, and you see a handy dandy chart that looks at where we are. So level zero is no AI. Level one, emerging AI. We're there. That's as far as we are.

Jeff Jarvis [01:40:29]:
There's.

Leo Laporte [01:40:30]:
I think we might be at level two, which is at least competent, at least 50th percentile of skilled adults. Are we not there? Somewhat. It says not yet achieved.

Jeff Jarvis [01:40:40]:
In general. That's not in general. Narrow, narrow, Certain areas.

Benito Gonzalez [01:40:45]:
Burger King drive through would disagree.

Leo Laporte [01:40:48]:
Yeah. It can't take orders. Yeah. Expert level is the 90th percentile of skilled adults.

Jeff Jarvis [01:40:56]:
And in certain areas, like Grammarly and spelling. Yes, but in general, no.

Leo Laporte [01:41:00]:
Yeah. Imogen. Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [01:41:02]:
99Th percent of skilled adults. Yes. Deep blue, yes.

Leo Laporte [01:41:06]:
Chess, sure.

Jeff Jarvis [01:41:07]:
But. But general, no. And then superhuman. This is the weird one. In specific, they say that Alpha Fold is superhuman. Yeah, I'll buy that. I agree with you.

Leo Laporte [01:41:16]:
So this is what to me is very interesting. And they also talk about the chess playing computers like Stockfish and Alphazer. What's very interesting to me, and I think really valuable is that in certain areas we do have superhuman intelligence.

Jeff Jarvis [01:41:29]:
Right. Which I think is what we should be concentrating on rather than who cares.

Leo Laporte [01:41:32]:
If it could do it in every area.

Jeff Jarvis [01:41:34]:
I agree. I agree. That's CGI bs.

Leo Laporte [01:41:37]:
Yeah, but we, I mean, look, you know, I'm very well aware that any. That even the simplest chess playing program on your phone can beat the best human players.

Jeff Jarvis [01:41:50]:
I can do a lot of stuff better than I can.

Leo Laporte [01:41:51]:
That's. That's. Yeah, I could do a lot of stuff better than you can. That's what Feynman was saying. He's saying, look, you know, we have cars that can go faster than any human. That's what happens.

Benito Gonzalez [01:42:01]:
You don't have to go. You don't have to go further than the calculator. You don't have to go past the calculator.

Leo Laporte [01:42:05]:
Calculator. Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.

Jeff Jarvis [01:42:08]:
But I like this. Just because it starts. The AGI is bs. It's never defined. This starts to get us to some clearer definition at least.

Leo Laporte [01:42:18]:
Yeah. Based on, like I said, I. Yeah. I don't really care about.

Benito Gonzalez [01:42:22]:
I mean, all we all this language, all this language though, really speaks to. Their actual goal is to replace people. Like, that's how.

Leo Laporte [01:42:31]:
That's how all this is a concern. Yeah, this is a concern. Yeah. But, you know, I think there's companies that end up replacing, and many are doing that now, replacing their human employees with AI are going to be. Sorry, I don't think in the long run these companies are going to be around.

Jeff Jarvis [01:42:50]:
Last week we talked about work slop that people are being forced to use stuff that's substandard and work with it. Yeah, I think it's because it's fomo.

Leo Laporte [01:43:01]:
This is one for you, Paris. Pissed off fans flooded the Twin Peaks subreddit with AI slop to protest its AI policies.

Jeff Jarvis [01:43:09]:
That's slop for good.

Paris Martineau [01:43:11]:
Slop for good.

Leo Laporte [01:43:12]:
Apparently people were posting.

Paris Martineau [01:43:16]:
There are some incredible images in this story, such as the log Lady Mackin with Dale Cooper.

Leo Laporte [01:43:24]:
Yeah, look at that. Oh, true love is happening there. I don't know what the bird's up to, but anyway, this looks like a human generated coal ash, to be honest. Nope, it's from rtwinpeaks. I know you're a Twin Peaks fan. Are you a follower of the subreddit?

Paris Martineau [01:43:44]:
I have. I recently left, actually, and not for this reason, but I'm sad I missed this.

Leo Laporte [01:43:52]:
So a moderator posted that the sub was a place for everyone to share memes, theories and quote anything remotely creative, as long as it has a loose string to the show or its case or its themes. AI generated content is included in all this.

Paris Martineau [01:44:07]:
Gosh, read the room tweet.

Leo Laporte [01:44:09]:
We're aware of how AI art and AI generated content can hurt real artists. Unfortunately, this is just the reality of the world we live in today. At this point, I don't think anything can stop the AI train from coming. It's here. It's only the beginning. AI content is becoming harder and harder to identify. That's. You know, I feel for the mod because that's part of the problem is how do you know? How can you tell?

Paris Martineau [01:44:30]:
Yeah, it's a really common moderation practice on Reddit and as someone who moderates a subreddit, it's not that hard.

Leo Laporte [01:44:39]:
Do you, you moderate a subreddit?

Paris Martineau [01:44:41]:
I do.

Leo Laporte [01:44:41]:
Is it on the. Is it on urban pruning? What is it? What is it?

Paris Martineau [01:44:44]:
I'm not going to specify what it is because that could lead you to my Reddit account, but I do moderate a subreddit that during various parts of the year has really high levels. Even during. Then we just put on the like moderation flow. We make it manual approved for posts. The Twin Peak suburb is not getting that high volume of like content being posted, but it is getting high enough volume that I just found it annoying after I'd finished watching.

Leo Laporte [01:45:13]:
Well, the thing that the mod did that annoyed people was he said, put flare on your post if it's AI so that people don't want to see AI can filter it out. Just tell us is all he's asking.

Paris Martineau [01:45:26]:
Listen, this is a reasonable approach. There's, I thought so wrong with that. However, you have any human with a semblance of sense or understanding of Reddit culture and the culture of Rounds Twin Peaks would see from a mile away that this was going to go terribly. There's no world in which this went well.

Leo Laporte [01:45:46]:
And of course the community that didn't want AI said, well, we're going to fill it with horrible AI. Here's Laura Palmer screaming above the stadium and the end, the end zone. Agent Cooper dancing. I like this. I don't know, it'd be nice if some human drew it. I agree, but a human didn't. So you can't be punk and also be anti AI, AI phobic or an AI denier. It's impossible.

Leo Laporte [01:46:13]:
Says David lynch in not in Reality. Although his hair is marvelous. That does look a lot like Lynch.

Paris Martineau [01:46:20]:
Yeah, I mean, I'm sure it is. A photo of his face put on.

Leo Laporte [01:46:25]:
Here's Obi Wan lynch talking to Sam Altman and I'm not sure who that is.

Benito Gonzalez [01:46:31]:
Natasha Leone.

Leo Laporte [01:46:33]:
Is it Natasha Leone? That kind of looks like. Okay, was she in Twin Peaks?

Paris Martineau [01:46:37]:
Okay, so. No, what this is a reference to is, I believe, Natasha Leone and. And someone else I'm ForGetting Started a AI startup that has something to do with Hollywood generation. We've. That's kind of like playing around the idea of using LMS and similar models for the generation of content for movies. And everybody was dunking on her for this. I believe we talked about this in the podcast some months ago and one of the things she said is that before David lynch died, Natasha Leone, she said in an interview with Vulture that she asked lynch for his thoughts on AI. And lynch picked up a pencil and told her that everyone has access to it and to a phone.

Paris Martineau [01:47:22]:
It's how you use the pencil, you.

Leo Laporte [01:47:24]:
See, it's how you use the pencil. It's how you use it. Right, Is what he's saying. It's a tool.

Jeff Jarvis [01:47:29]:
It's how fair.

Leo Laporte [01:47:30]:
And it's how you use it. It's a tool and it's how use It.

Paris Martineau [01:47:33]:
Yeah, I mean, in. Why are they upset about British. Well, part of the thing is, in a previous British Film Institute interview right before his death, lynch lauded AI said it was incredibly useful as a tool for creativity and for machines to help create creativity. However, AI booster. As 404 notes in the story, AI boosters often leave off the second part of the quote, which was, I'm sure with all these things, if money is the bottom line, there'd be a lot of sad sadness and despair and horror, but I'm hoping better times are coming.

Leo Laporte [01:48:04]:
Well, that's true in general. Right. I mean, maybe the criticism of this is really more a criticism of late stage capitalism than anything else.

Paris Martineau [01:48:11]:
Yes, but it's still a criticism.

Leo Laporte [01:48:13]:
Yeah, no, I, I would agree with you on that. I just, I mean, I wouldn't tar AI with that brush. You could tar everything with that brush. That's why I mentioned Amazon fulfillment centers. I mean. Yeah, yeah.

Benito Gonzalez [01:48:25]:
How many people have already stopped buying from Amazon?

Leo Laporte [01:48:27]:
A lot of people. Right. Well, and this is. I mean, let's hope the market responds and steers us in a better direction.

Benito Gonzalez [01:48:35]:
But you wouldn't call it bigoted for people not buying Amazon from Amazon anymore, right?

Leo Laporte [01:48:39]:
No, no. And if you want to boycott AI, go right ahead. I think that's appropriate.

Paris Martineau [01:48:43]:
Oh, but if you make fun of it and call it slop, then you're a bigot.

Leo Laporte [01:48:46]:
Well, I think calling it slop is minimizing.

Paris Martineau [01:48:52]:
If you call someone a hog sucker, which is now what some people are calling slucker fans, and I'm pronounce that very carefully. You do not mishear me, listeners, and send LEO emails about me poisoning your children's ears. I forgot.

Leo Laporte [01:49:10]:
Has now passed. If you wanted a certified financial analyst, AI has, or chartered, I should say financial analyst, AI has, by the way, a certification that requires thousands of hours of professional experience and a very rigorous exam. According to Verify Investopedia, it is one of the most respected designations in finance. Well, guess what?

Jeff Jarvis [01:49:31]:
It says a lot about exams as a test.

Leo Laporte [01:49:34]:
Yeah, maybe that's more about exams. In a new study from the Stern School of business at NYU, advanced AI like Gemini 2.5 Pro and Claude Opus, passed the exam with flying colors. Took AI just a matter of minutes to do what a human might take a thousand hours of study studying over multiple years to do. In fact, two years ago, AI models could only pass the first two sections of the three part exam. So there AI passing the CFA in minutes while humans cry over flashcards for years. At this point, the calculator Deserves a corner office.

Benito Gonzalez [01:50:12]:
Hey, if the people had access to the Internet, they would be able to do it too.

Leo Laporte [01:50:16]:
Ah, good point. Yeah. I was never impressed with Watson winning Jeopardy. I mean, if I could instantly look up the answers on the Internet, I would win too.

Jeff Jarvis [01:50:25]:
But in the day, the fact that Watson could understand the question was a big deal.

Leo Laporte [01:50:28]:
In the day, I understand the question. Right. Not answer. We knew it could answer it. Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [01:50:36]:
ChatGPT is now 20% of Walmart's referral traffic.

Leo Laporte [01:50:41]:
So it does send traffic.

Jeff Jarvis [01:50:43]:
It does send traffic. Now Ben Evans points out that that referrals are. Only 5% of Walmart people go directly to the Walmart brand. But there's a lesson in there for media that says that that's just chatgpt. Right. There's others. And this is, this is our conversation with Rich Squinta from from Common Crawl. If you cut yourself off from AI, you cut yourself off from these referrals.

Jeff Jarvis [01:51:03]:
Brands are dying to be in AI because they want those referrals instead of media where they got to pay.

Leo Laporte [01:51:09]:
Right.

Jeff Jarvis [01:51:09]:
And so media are being stupid by saying, no, no, no, no, no, you can't, you can't know that we exist.

Leo Laporte [01:51:15]:
Jammer B, who is a Jeopardy expert, says no, no, the AI understood the answers and provided the questions. Let's get this right.

Jeff Jarvis [01:51:25]:
There be points lost. You couldn't be more right.

Leo Laporte [01:51:34]:
Amazon had its big event yesterday. They announced a bunch of new gadgets. A Kindle scribe and color. Maybe that's the. I know you were looking Paris for something to write notes in. The kine scribe is a nice big format device. Did you ever find a device? I will send you my scribe, my old scribe. You want to try it? You can have it.

Paris Martineau [01:51:53]:
Yeah, I'll borrow it. I'm trying to decide whether I want to get a remarkable or a scribe or something else. I wish there was a place that I could go and test all of.

Leo Laporte [01:52:04]:
These because what you want to do is very specific.

Paris Martineau [01:52:07]:
Yeah, I want to use it to. I have. I'm surrounded currently on my desk with papers marked up and studies and handwritten notes and I want to be able to mark up my PDFs both in highlight and like pen marks in a way that's searchable but then also take notes and ideally I like taking notes in color so I'd want to be able to do that. I also though like to be able to read books on the thing because I like the E ink display.

Jeff Jarvis [01:52:37]:
Paris, it's not E Ink. I didn't do the E Ink because I Didn't want to have to download everything that I was going to annotate and then re upload it and worry about that. So the reason I went with the Android tablet is because I can just use Google Drive there just like I want my phone. And so when I open a document, I'm opening it on Google Drive and when I close it, it stays on Google Drive. The disadvantage is that unlike my laptop, if I don't save it before I close the machine, then I lose my annotations. That's sucky.

Paris Martineau [01:53:12]:
That's wild.

Jeff Jarvis [01:53:13]:
It's like the old control S comes back. Now I did try to start using highlighting in colors and such on my black and white printer. That doesn't come out and neither does color written. So now I use black. But if I have a color printer.

Paris Martineau [01:53:31]:
Do you have a white printer?

Jeff Jarvis [01:53:32]:
I do, yeah. And you know, I still have a phone with a cord.

Paris Martineau [01:53:35]:
I've got a printer, but it's a color printer. Because you said I got rid of the facts, make wise choices.

Jeff Jarvis [01:53:41]:
Well, because I was printing out tons and tons and tons of pages and a few years ago it was cheaper to get a laser with just print prints.

Leo Laporte [01:53:47]:
I guess that's true. Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis [01:53:48]:
I can read books on it. I can watch movies on it. You know, I can watch.

Paris Martineau [01:53:55]:
I don't know. There is something that I find just kind of nice about the fact that they're remarkable tablets. I can't really do anything other than like look at documents and read stuff, but I think it's ridiculous that they're not EPUB competitors. And I also don't want to have to do like a subscription service to access my own files on my computer. I don't know. This is going to be a thing I'm going to probably bring up again and again over the podcast over the.

Jeff Jarvis [01:54:18]:
Next when Leo comes to town and we meet you and I can sit down with my tablet.

Paris Martineau [01:54:22]:
Yeah, Leo, you can. Can bring a. I'll bring the switch. You can bring a switch with a pentiment for Jeff and a for me.

Leo Laporte [01:54:31]:
Yeah. Oh, that's a good point. Yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:54:33]:
Devices for your pod friend.

Jeff Jarvis [01:54:36]:
Now, now, Leo, when you do come, do you think you'll have the time that we can go to the Amazon warehouse?

Paris Martineau [01:54:41]:
Yes, please add an extra day to your trips that we can do.

Jeff Jarvis [01:54:44]:
A versus Broadway.

Paris Martineau [01:54:46]:
It was team building, outing.

Leo Laporte [01:54:48]:
It was never, never a question of time, Jeff. It was more a question of volition.

Jeff Jarvis [01:54:54]:
Broadway or Amazon.

Leo Laporte [01:54:57]:
You know, do I really want to.

Paris Martineau [01:54:58]:
Sing while we're there?

Leo Laporte [01:55:01]:
What would, what would be the argument to go visit the Amazon warehouse because.

Jeff Jarvis [01:55:05]:
You'Re a geek and it'd be fun.

Paris Martineau [01:55:06]:
We could go to the Rainforest Cafe in New Jersey on the way.

Leo Laporte [01:55:09]:
Forest Cafe. I don't need to go again.

Jeff Jarvis [01:55:11]:
We could go to the Times in.

Paris Martineau [01:55:13]:
New Jersey on the way back.

Jeff Jarvis [01:55:15]:
We could go to the, to the, the Farm, where there's. Where you can play with golden retrievers.

Leo Laporte [01:55:22]:
New Jersey. Is there anything you can't do?

Paris Martineau [01:55:25]:
Isn't there a computer medium there, too, Jeff?

Jeff Jarvis [01:55:28]:
No. There's the Green Book Electronics, which is the store where you could actually buy these things. You can see these amazing.

Leo Laporte [01:55:34]:
I, I can see nobody's interested in any of the things Amazon announced. And in fact, we agreed, I think we agreed on this on MacBreak weekly yesterday, that everything Amazon makes and sells is basically a platform for Amazon advertising, and there's no reason anybody should buy any of it.

Jeff Jarvis [01:55:50]:
Yeah, I never hear you after these announcements say, well, I have to order this, I have to test it out. Right. When was the last time you bought an Amazon thing?

Leo Laporte [01:55:57]:
I bought an. I wanted it when I wanted to try the new Echo AI. I had in my head. I read somewhere that if you bought a new Echo device, you'd be able to. To jump the line. And I, So I bought an Echo show, of which I already have many, but I bought a new one. And no, it didn't help. In fact, Lisa got an invitation to Amazon Echo AI before I did.

Leo Laporte [01:56:21]:
So I don't understand how any of this works. I, you know, I was a little tempted maybe by the new Echo Studio, which they say is the best audio speaker anywhere, and I doubt very much it is. And the problem is, when you talk to Amazon's Echo, it's always saying things like, you know, you can buy something, it's always an ad. And the same thing with the Fire TV and their TVs. And I just can't get behind the Amazon stuff anymore. And I've abandoned my. I used to have a lot of Kindles. I went through a bunch of Kindles, but I like the Kobo a little bit better.

Leo Laporte [01:56:58]:
Very happy with the color code.

Jeff Jarvis [01:56:59]:
Now, what about the Kobo scribe is.

Leo Laporte [01:57:01]:
That I have a Kobo Libra color. I have the Amazon scribe, which is big. It's not color. The new one's color. So if you want color. But you know, color on E ink is very washed out. I'm not sure I'd recommend. I mean, I don't know how important color is.

Jeff Jarvis [01:57:18]:
Paris, when you were working on paper, did you take different colored Pens to make different colored marks. Oh, she does.

Leo Laporte [01:57:26]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:57:26]:
Look at all these colors.

Leo Laporte [01:57:28]:
Oh, it won't be. It won't be. Yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:57:31]:
That's not even. This isn't even my only supply of colors. I've run out of space.

Leo Laporte [01:57:37]:
Stick with paper.

Jeff Jarvis [01:57:38]:
Yeah.

Benito Gonzalez [01:57:38]:
Why would you go digital? You have all the tools.

Leo Laporte [01:57:40]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:57:42]:
There is something that would be useful about being able to.

Benito Gonzalez [01:57:47]:
I control that. Yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:57:49]:
I get this right now. It would be great to be able to control f. Currently on my desk, I have dozen probably like 50 sheets of paper that are. I could search through with my hands right now, but they're covered in various drinks and snacks and other objects, and that's just difficult.

Leo Laporte [01:58:08]:
Are you ready for a new version of Amazon or Anthropics? Claude that can code for 30 hours straight without a break?

Jeff Jarvis [01:58:17]:
What did Musk call that?

Paris Martineau [01:58:19]:
Did they give the. Did they give Claude those lazine, what's called, Zyn packets?

Leo Laporte [01:58:26]:
Oh, the snooze. Yeah, yeah.

Paris Martineau [01:58:28]:
Did they give. Did they give it nicotine? Is that what's happening? Is it Celsius?

Leo Laporte [01:58:32]:
Claude Sonnet 4.5, the latest model, spent 30 hours running by itself to code a chat app like Slack or Teams. It span out about 11,000 lines of code according to Anthropic, and only stopped when it had completed the task.

Jeff Jarvis [01:58:48]:
Well, what a good employee.

Leo Laporte [01:58:50]:
Wow. That's basically what they're saying.

Paris Martineau [01:58:53]:
Okay, but my question is, did the thing at Code did work? It didn't.

Leo Laporte [01:58:58]:
Oh, you know, I wish they would release this. No thing that.

Paris Martineau [01:59:01]:
The only things they've said are like, yeah, it spent all these hours doing on it. It had thousands of lines, lines of code. How cool. And I'm like, but did it. Did it work?

Jeff Jarvis [01:59:11]:
Then?

Benito Gonzalez [01:59:11]:
How long did the engineers have to take to debug it?

Jeff Jarvis [01:59:14]:
Yes, they're all going to be replaced. If you work for. For. For Accenture, you have to do AI or you'll be replaced. I love. This is my favorite line, my favorite CEO speak. We are investing in upskilling our reinventors, which is our primary strategy. We are exiting on a compressed timeline, people where reskilling based on our experience is not a viable path for the skills we need.

Leo Laporte [01:59:42]:
There's a blind wiz in our discord, our Club Twit Discord said, Claude Sonnet 4.5 is actually really great. I ran it yesterday for 10 hours. Darren is saying, yeah, it comes up with working code. It actually does stuff that really works a lot of our. We'll talk about this on Friday in our AI user group by the way, if you're a club twit member, I think this will be one of the things we'll talk about. But I really think that this is one of the areas.

Jeff Jarvis [02:00:09]:
Where is Claude the Outfront winner still on coding?

Leo Laporte [02:00:13]:
I think so. I mean, OpenAI keeps coming out with updated versions of its codex now, by the way, OpenAI has released Chat GPT Pulse, which does personalized research on your behalf overnight and then serves you up access to this. I don't know. Not I.

Paris Martineau [02:00:33]:
This is the thing is they. I refuse to personally cover. Obviously we can talk about this for the show, but I've seen people tweeting about this going around. Oh, Pulse. So cool. I don't know anybody who has.

Leo Laporte [02:00:47]:
Maybe if you pay for the $200.

Jeff Jarvis [02:00:49]:
A month pro, I think you get it.

Leo Laporte [02:00:50]:
Yes.

Paris Martineau [02:00:51]:
You get early access to it. Okay. It's a feature for a very small amount of people right now. It will be interesting.

Leo Laporte [02:00:57]:
And Darren, have you. Have you used it? Darren Oki or. I can't remember if you have Pro.

Jeff Jarvis [02:01:03]:
Pro plan.

Leo Laporte [02:01:04]:
Darren has the pro plan on Claude.

Jeff Jarvis [02:01:06]:
No, no, not on Pro, he says. I'm confused. Darren.

Leo Laporte [02:01:08]:
Ah, okay. He's on Claude. Max. Oh, he uses it though. He's a coder. He knows what he's doing.

Benito Gonzalez [02:01:18]:
How come Max doesn't have everything? How come Max. Isn't that supposed to. Supposed to be the maximum? Like what?

Leo Laporte [02:01:22]:
It's the Max.

Paris Martineau [02:01:23]:
Well, it's not. It's not super Max plus Yeah.

Leo Laporte [02:01:26]:
Poor Marissa. Remember we were talking about her. Her old startup Sunrise, which was supposed to be.

Paris Martineau [02:01:34]:
Isn't it Sunshine?

Jeff Jarvis [02:01:35]:
Sunshine.

Leo Laporte [02:01:35]:
Sunshine. Sunshine is setting. It's now Sunset.

Jeff Jarvis [02:01:39]:
That was. That was going to be contacts.

Leo Laporte [02:01:41]:
She has a new AI startup called Dazzle because the sun has shown and now we're dazzled by. Is an AI personal assistant, which is something we would all like.

Jeff Jarvis [02:01:55]:
Years ago I spoke with her and I talked about hyperlocal news and she said, no, Jeff, you're completely wrong. The future is hyper personal.

Leo Laporte [02:02:03]:
Well, she's certainly working toward that.

Jeff Jarvis [02:02:04]:
Working on it.

Leo Laporte [02:02:05]:
Yeah. Sunshine. I did pay for it. It was a contact management app. Yes. The product saw, according to TechCrunch, little adoption due to privacy concerns and pretty much languished. Both apps have been downloaded just over a thousand times on the Google Play store. They raised $20 million in 2020, but according to Meyer, was largely self funded.

Leo Laporte [02:02:34]:
So she put in a lot of her own.

Jeff Jarvis [02:02:35]:
And they've sold all of the assets from Sunshine to Dazzle.

Leo Laporte [02:02:39]:
To Dazzle.

Jeff Jarvis [02:02:40]:
It's now Dazzle for How much I don't know.

Paris Martineau [02:02:43]:
A brief aside. I was looking up more details about ChatGPT plus, went to OpenAI's FAQ page for Chat B Plus. Scrolled down to the bottom. It had some other like, little things in the FAQ, like, what is ChatGPT plus? And then they had one. Does Chat GPT tell the truth? And I was like, oh, that's a fun one. I wonder what they say you click. Said we can't. It was a complete error the first 12 times I clicked it.

Paris Martineau [02:03:10]:
Now, of course, that I'm reading it was the air. It has worked.

Leo Laporte [02:03:13]:
Wow. But you know, does it tell the truth? Does it say.

Paris Martineau [02:03:18]:
It says ChatGPT can be helpful, but it's not always right.

Leo Laporte [02:03:23]:
I mean, I think that's one of the things that people are saying is it's trying to tell. If it doesn't know the answer, it makes one up because it really wants to give you an answer.

Jeff Jarvis [02:03:32]:
That's the issue. We had that paper from them a few weeks ago where they're trying to get it to say, I don't know. But it doesn't. It doesn't know anything. It has no sense of meaning. So it can't know what it doesn't know.

Paris Martineau [02:03:45]:
Confidence isn't reliability. It says the model may express high confidence even in incorrect acts.

Leo Laporte [02:03:51]:
That's good. That's good that they say that. That's good.

Benito Gonzalez [02:03:55]:
To the five people who read the faq.

Leo Laporte [02:03:57]:
Yeah, I bury it right in the faq. Let's take a break and we will continue with more. Actually, I think we're ready for the picks of the week, to be honest with you. I think we're ready. It's 4:20. You know what that means. It's time for Elon Musk to start another company. No, it's time for a break.

Leo Laporte [02:04:17]:
And we do have a new fat bear champion. We will report on that.

Jeff Jarvis [02:04:24]:
Pictures.

Leo Laporte [02:04:25]:
Is. Is he skinny now? Is he fat?

Jeff Jarvis [02:04:28]:
He's fat now. It's a new fat one. Even with a handicap. It's got a bear handicap and came out number one.

Leo Laporte [02:04:36]:
Oh, and I want to talk about some misreporting that we did not participate in. I was glad I held off. Remember the Secret Service finding a giant SIM farm in New York City that was ostensibly going to be used to DDoS, the phone system in New York.

Jeff Jarvis [02:04:54]:
City and for the. When the UN was in town to cause international crisis?

Leo Laporte [02:04:59]:
Yeah. No, no, no. Experts in the area say, no, that's not what it was.

Jeff Jarvis [02:05:04]:
Just plain old crime.

Leo Laporte [02:05:05]:
Just plain old crime. And there are many of them apparently everywhere in the world, these SIM farms. The New York Times and many other news organizations repeated the Secret Service's press release, saying they foiled a national security threat. According to, and I believe him, Robert Graham in his Cybersect newsletter, he said the story's bogus. What they discovered was just normal criminal enterprise. Banks of thousands of cell phones used to send spam or forward international calls using local phone numbers. Technically, it may even be a legitimate enterprise, being simply a gateway between a legitimate VoIP provider and the mobile phone network. But the Secret Service really wanted you to think they had foiled an international plot against the United Nations.

Leo Laporte [02:05:58]:
Secret Service is lying to the press, he says. They know it's just a normal criminal sim farm and are hyping it to some sort of national security or espionage threat. We know this because they're using the correct technical terms that demonstrate their understanding of typical SIM farm crimes. The claim that they will likely find other such SIM farms in other cities likewise shows they understand this is a normal criminal activity and not any special national security threat. So I'm glad I did not bite on that bait. We'll be back with your picks of the week in just a moment. Our show today brought to you by the Agency Build the future of Multi Agent software with Agency Agntcy it's now an open source Linux foundation project. Agency is building the Internet of Agents, a collaboration layer where AI agents can discover, connect and work across any framework.

Leo Laporte [02:06:58]:
All the pieces engineers need to deploy multi agent systems now belong to anyone and everyone who builds on Agency, including robust identity and access management that ensures every agent is authenticated and trusted before interacting. Agency also provides open standardized tools for agent discovery, seamless protocols for agent to agent communication, and modular components for scalable workflows. Collaborate with developers from Cisco, Dell Technologies, Google Cloud, Oracle, Red Hat and 75/ other supporting companies to build next gen AI infrastructure together. Agency is dropping code specs and services. No strings attached. Visit agency.org to contribute. That's a G N T C y.org we thank them so much for their support of intelligent machines. This is a worthy effort and we're glad to help promote the agency.

Leo Laporte [02:07:57]:
Is there anything else before we get to the picks?

Jeff Jarvis [02:07:59]:
Because I quick follow up. The judge has approved a preliminary approval to the Anthropic settlement.

Leo Laporte [02:08:04]:
Really?

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:05]:
Because we talked about that. That's down.

Leo Laporte [02:08:07]:
So this is a big deal because remember129 the authors who were suing OpenAI? I'm sorry anthropic agreed to a settlement. A $1.5 billion settlement which would have given each of the authors. What was it, $3,000 per book.

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:22]:
It's what it would work out. But they're not. It's not certain. That was just the division and the.

Leo Laporte [02:08:26]:
Judge in the matter. I think it's. Judge Alsip said. Wait a minute.

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:30]:
He was concerned about how much was going to the lawyers.

Leo Laporte [02:08:32]:
Yeah. He didn't like. But apparently now he's given them the go ahead.

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:36]:
Right. And now it has blessed the payment process under which authors and publishers of trade books would split the reward. Oh, sorry. Authors.

Leo Laporte [02:08:45]:
Publishers get a little bit.

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:47]:
Publishers get a lot. The publishers always get the biggest share.

Leo Laporte [02:08:49]:
Oh, yeah. Because they're doing all the work. Oh, no.

Jeff Jarvis [02:08:54]:
That's what they think. So that's just worthy follow up because we thought, that's interesting.

Leo Laporte [02:09:00]:
It could have been bad. It could have been trillions of dollars for Anthropic. So Anthropic's breathing a sigh of relief. And of course, the first part of Judge Alsop's decision was really good because it said that that was, at least in my opinion. Maybe you guys don't agree, but it said that it was a fair use if you bought the books and then scanned them. That that was fair use and protected. Oh, good. All right, well, I'm kind of glad that this is behind us.

Leo Laporte [02:09:25]:
Right.

Jeff Jarvis [02:09:27]:
And one little bit of change law.

Leo Laporte [02:09:30]:
Yes. From Google. Yes.

Jeff Jarvis [02:09:32]:
It's official.

Leo Laporte [02:09:33]:
Yes.

Jeff Jarvis [02:09:33]:
Google says Android and Chrome OS will merge next year.

Leo Laporte [02:09:36]:
Ah. Wow. That's a big deal.

Jeff Jarvis [02:09:40]:
Yeah, it is.

Leo Laporte [02:09:42]:
And now a word from Foom. It's a moose skull. Spooky moose skull. That's perfect for the eternal night by Golden AI Studios.

Jeff Jarvis [02:10:01]:
Beauty now.

Leo Laporte [02:10:02]:
Yeah. So Foom is, as we mentioned earlier, it's broadcasting the acceleration 24. 7. This is Runway. These are all.

Jeff Jarvis [02:10:11]:
And these do come with credits to creators at the end. If you scrub back and forth, you'll find various.

Leo Laporte [02:10:18]:
So what's interesting. Yeah, no, I see it even at the bottom. So what's interesting, of course, is that Runway was one of the first models to generate video. But now I think with sound down and vo.

Paris Martineau [02:10:29]:
I was going to say, whose video? Whose music?

Jeff Jarvis [02:10:32]:
Whose music is that?

Leo Laporte [02:10:33]:
Well, I think it's probably all part of the Golden AI Studio creation. Let's just say this so you could watch this 24. 7 and.

Jeff Jarvis [02:10:43]:
Oh, yeah.

Leo Laporte [02:10:44]:
Yeah. See, this isn't sloppy. This is a nightmare.

Jeff Jarvis [02:10:51]:
You bigot.

Paris Martineau [02:10:53]:
Yeah, you cog sucker.

Leo Laporte [02:10:55]:
Yeah, I just, you know, clanker and cog sucker. I think they're just you know, they're, they're unnecessarily negative. Just call me a boomer. Okay, Just, just let's leave lead with that. Paris. Your pick of the week.

Paris Martineau [02:11:09]:
Cog suckers and slops accelerationists. Well, you know, we were just talking about a a slot powered 24 hour livestream of content created by who knows what sort of clankers. What if I told you you could have that experience but have it be all human created and be part of what some people are saying the strangest game of is the strangest game of the year. It is called Blippo plus. I have not played this, but I just realized it's out and I'm going to be playing is Here is how the Verge describes it in its review. I'm not sure if Blipo plus is actually a game, but it's worth checking out. It's more of a alien television simulator created artists and developers made up of of yacht tell a bunch of different studios. Basically you this originally debuted in the Play Date console, but it recently was made available to Steam and Nintendo Switch.

Paris Martineau [02:12:24]:
You don't.

Leo Laporte [02:12:24]:
So you could put this on your Switch?

Paris Martineau [02:12:26]:
Yes. So you don't really play a game. The idea is here I'll read from the Verge because I think it's funny. The idea is that for reasons that aren't immediately clear, you're able to turn it tune into a TV network from another world, the titular Blippo Plus. You don't really play the game, but rather flip around the channels. There's FMV shows, human actors covering everything from dramas to cooking. And to better understand the alien culture, it's a kind of full color follow up to a Play Date game that was on the second season. Over time you start it's kind of also like an ARG basically because over time you start to notice connections between all the different disparate channels.

Paris Martineau [02:13:08]:
There's also kind of strange phenomenon going on to the viewer and the story. It's also all happening like live on a schedule. So there's no way to like you played it and it's no, but I've been literally meaning to play. I I've had it on my calendar for it comes out at the end of September.

Leo Laporte [02:13:26]:
Is there. Is there a game? I mean what I don't win? Do you?

Paris Martineau [02:13:30]:
I don't think you win. I think the game is art that you're participating in trying to figure out. It's like it's a game in the same way that like an arg, like an alternate reality game is A game and like you're kind of trying to figure out the mystery and what connects all of this. It's all kind of in like a strange low budget.

Leo Laporte [02:13:48]:
So there is a story somewhere.

Paris Martineau [02:13:49]:
There's a story. There isn't much interaction besides like changing the channel, but at various points you have to adjust like your picture so you can see things clearly, check your messages. But basically it, from what I've heard it happens in like a multi week timeline. So like, like you just can have it on in the background. Be passively consuming Blippo plus to try and piece together the story. And if you like miss those couple of weeks of Blippo plus, you've missed those couple of weeks of Blippo Plus. I don't know, it sounds great.

Benito Gonzalez [02:14:21]:
It's like a movie that's all weekends.

Jeff Jarvis [02:14:23]:
It's like all lore.

Raisa Martin [02:14:25]:
It's.

Paris Martineau [02:14:25]:
Yeah, an oops. All lore situation. Here's some of the headlines.

Leo Laporte [02:14:31]:
Is this better because it was created by human humans?

Paris Martineau [02:14:33]:
Yes. Okay, here's some of the headlines for reviews about this game published by Game Places. The strangest game of the year is a channel thing simulator. Blippo plus is an interactive. I think you should leave for aliens Blippo plus review. I promise you've never played anything like this. Blippo plus is a weird retro cable TV art project disguised as a game.

Leo Laporte [02:14:59]:
And travel back to the game. Somebody put a lot of energy and effort into this.

Paris Martineau [02:15:02]:
I mean, I mean it's a game. It's a game released by like a dozen different studios at once. I will be tuning in to Blippo plus.

Leo Laporte [02:15:12]:
So let us know if you win.

Paris Martineau [02:15:14]:
I will. I'll let you know if I become the alien God.

Leo Laporte [02:15:17]:
So it was on playdate, but this is obviously in color and much more resolution. This is.

Raisa Martin [02:15:22]:
Yes.

Paris Martineau [02:15:23]:
So I had heard about this because all the weird art freaks that I follow or freaking out about it when it comes to.

Leo Laporte [02:15:29]:
I gave away my play date. I bought the play date and I just didn't get it and I gave it away. I should have given it to you, Paris. And I apologize.

Paris Martineau [02:15:37]:
You should have. And I accept your apology in the form of a couple of E Ink tablets. But yeah, I was just, I was excited whenever it was going to come to my Steam deck. So I'll check it out now.

Leo Laporte [02:15:51]:
Good. Jeff Jarvis.

Jeff Jarvis [02:15:54]:
Well, it was time for the bears. More fat bears now. Line 193, the Guardian provides. Provides a handy slider to see before and after of the winning bears.

Leo Laporte [02:16:03]:
Thank you. Much better than the New York Times. Did.

Paris Martineau [02:16:06]:
Thanks God.

Leo Laporte [02:16:06]:
Yes.

Jeff Jarvis [02:16:07]:
Derek Spiegel did it too. But I think the guardians are good.

Leo Laporte [02:16:10]:
Okay, so this is we talked about last week. A hundred thousand votes. 100,000 votes.

Jeff Jarvis [02:16:17]:
32.

Leo Laporte [02:16:17]:
Chunk chunk. 32. Chunk wins even though he had a broken jaw. And let's take a look. This is. This is before. This is in June. And then of course remember he's getting ready to hibernate.

Leo Laporte [02:16:32]:
Right. So as he.

Jeff Jarvis [02:16:34]:
As he beats hot dog contest is coming up and Chunk is ready.

Leo Laporte [02:16:38]:
He is getting fatter and fatter.

Paris Martineau [02:16:42]:
Chunk. That's 32 whole chunks.

Leo Laporte [02:16:45]:
That is a lot.

Jeff Jarvis [02:16:46]:
There's some more below some of them. Some of the losers are below. The rudder is up.

Leo Laporte [02:16:51]:
Bear 901 before and after. Yeah, I think he did a pretty good job of chunking.

Paris Martineau [02:16:55]:
He dethroned one.

Leo Laporte [02:16:57]:
Do they make a zempic for bears? I mean bear zempic.

Paris Martineau [02:17:01]:
I think it's called hibernation. Yeah. Yeah.

Leo Laporte [02:17:04]:
Right?

Jeff Jarvis [02:17:05]:
It is. It is impressive how much they.

Leo Laporte [02:17:07]:
Yeah. Holy cow. Wow.

Jeff Jarvis [02:17:10]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [02:17:10]:
I'm gonna go. I'm gonna search fat bears live now just for the the thrill of it.

Leo Laporte [02:17:16]:
Yeah. The fat bear competition this year we should note in a sad note was delayed after one of the contestants was killed by another less fat bear which was also captured in the live stream.

Jeff Jarvis [02:17:31]:
Kids, don't watch this.

Leo Laporte [02:17:32]:
Chunk, who in the summer of 2024 killed the cub of a reigning fat bear champion. The death was captured also 128 grazier beat chunk in the fat bear competition by more than 40,000 votes. After that heinous act. Despite this is the Guardian. Despite his role as the villain in previous years, Chunk, who has narrowly set eyes, dark brown fur and a prominent brow ridge and distinctive scar across his muzzle, won over the public this year with his story of perseverance. That's because he had a freshly broken jaw. Wild bears, we should point out, do not receive veterinary care. There's no doctor out there.

Paris Martineau [02:18:13]:
I would just like to point out that the explore.org website where you go to if you. You're brought to if you search Fat bears live cam. Now the header if you go to the homepage is just a picture of what I assume is Chunk with the words fall in love with the world again. And I just. I thought we all needed to know that.

Jeff Jarvis [02:18:35]:
We do.

Leo Laporte [02:18:38]:
I can't explain our obsession with fat bears. I can't explain it, but there it is.

Jeff Jarvis [02:18:45]:
And then while Jony I've is going to create the winning AI device we're all waiting for, he's got to bide some time and create other things. So he created a $4,800 lantern.

Leo Laporte [02:18:57]:
Oh. But it's ready to survive the toughest marine environments. Maritime environments. Right.

Jeff Jarvis [02:19:04]:
For that price, I wouldn't want to take it out in the boat for fear of getting it wet.

Leo Laporte [02:19:07]:
Oh, it's. It's. Oh, don't. No. Don't be fooled by this. It is made for boating love. From which is Jony Ives design firm did it in collaboration with Balmuda. Get ready.

Leo Laporte [02:19:21]:
Here comes the $5,000 maritime lantern.

Paris Martineau [02:19:26]:
Frankly, I.

Leo Laporte [02:19:28]:
It's pretty.

Paris Martineau [02:19:29]:
Expect it to look pretty. Look better for $5,000 at that small size.

Leo Laporte [02:19:33]:
It's functional. It's a functional sailing lantern.

Paris Martineau [02:19:35]:
I guess it's easy to maintain, disassemble and repair and recycle at the end of a lifetime of use.

Leo Laporte [02:19:41]:
Yeah.

Paris Martineau [02:19:41]:
So that's. And it has a goal. It's gold.

Leo Laporte [02:19:45]:
I wonder how many they think they're gonna sell.

Paris Martineau [02:19:47]:
Well, they only made a thousand of.

Leo Laporte [02:19:49]:
Them, so they don't care.

Jeff Jarvis [02:19:51]:
Get them while they're hot.

Leo Laporte [02:19:52]:
Well, they're customer yacht.

Benito Gonzalez [02:19:55]:
Their whole customer base is yacht owners. So, you know.

Leo Laporte [02:19:58]:
Yeah. If you have a $70 million yacht, a $5,000 lantern is cheap.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:02]:
Let's get five cheap.

Paris Martineau [02:20:03]:
Hey guys. It's actually a huge steal because in the box you also get a cleaning cloth.

Leo Laporte [02:20:11]:
Apple charges separately for those. By the way, you can tell Jony I've is a famous designer because he wears his glasses differently than you. And I don't know why he chose that as his headshot, but he did.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:23]:
Paris, let's do it.

Leo Laporte [02:20:25]:
Everybody should wear. There you go.

Paris Martineau [02:20:27]:
And then Leo, you look panicked that you don't have glasses.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:30]:
He really was.

Leo Laporte [02:20:31]:
I can find.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:32]:
Where's my glasses? Get some glasses. We gotta do this. For bonito.

Leo Laporte [02:20:36]:
For bonito.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:37]:
Bonito. Moment.

Benito Gonzalez [02:20:42]:
All right.

Leo Laporte [02:20:43]:
Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.

Paris Martineau [02:20:47]:
I have no idea what that looked like because I didn't have my glasses.

Jeff Jarvis [02:20:50]:
Exactly.

Leo Laporte [02:20:51]:
Wonderful. Yeah, it was all blue blurry. Thank you for joining us for intelligent machines. Thanks to our special guest as well. It was a fascinating story. Even though she is apparently creating AI slop@hux.com.

Jeff Jarvis [02:21:05]:
No, she's not.

Leo Laporte [02:21:06]:
Thanks to Risa Martin. It was great to have her on the show. Thanks to all of you, especially all you club twit members who make this show possible with your very valuable membership. 25% of our operating expenses come from you. And man, I'd like everybody to join the club because that's just. It's a way of voting for the content. Now if you Hate the content, don't join the club. But if you want to hear more of this kind of trivia and piffle and nonsense, go to Twit TV clubtwit.

Leo Laporte [02:21:35]:
I should mention our AI user group is coming up in the club on Friday. Anthony Nielsen leads that every month, usually the third or sorry, the first Friday of the month. And that's what this is. 2pm Pacific, 5pm Eastern. We also have the book club coming up, the photo time with Chris Marquardt. All of this by way of giving you club members something a little extra value in Paris. You're going to participate in Micah's Dungeons and Dragons.

Paris Martineau [02:22:02]:
I'm so excited for this. Leo and I are both going to participate.

Leo Laporte [02:22:06]:
Paul Thurot, who I did not know.

Paris Martineau [02:22:09]:
Have you played Dungeons and Dragons before?

Leo Laporte [02:22:11]:
I have not. Paul Therot is a former dungeon master in his youth. Of course you're a DND player. Yes, I mean I am, but I'm.

Paris Martineau [02:22:21]:
Not very experienced at it, so I'll have fun with my friends.

Leo Laporte [02:22:25]:
I'm a complete noob, so this will be interesting. We're going to ask some of our club members to join us. Anyway, a lot of good reasons to join the club, including ad free versions of all the shows. Visit TWiT TV Club TWiT. Thank you in advance. Now we do this show every Wednesday right after Windows Weekly. That's 2pm Pacific, 5pm Eastern, 2100 UTC. You can watch us live as we're doing it.

Leo Laporte [02:22:49]:
If you're in the club of course in the Discord, but everybody else can watch on YouTube, Twitch, TikTok, X.com, facebook, LinkedIn and Kik. We're everywhere after the fact. On demand versions of the show are available, audio or video your choice at our website Twitt TV IM. There's video on the YouTube channel dedicated to intelligent machines. And of course the best way to get it is subscribe and your favorite podcast client. That way you'll get it automatically as soon as it's done. And that's free to do. Thank you for being here.

Leo Laporte [02:23:21]:
Paris Martineau is at Consumer Reports. Did you see by the way, we have to add to the radioactive shrimp.

Paris Martineau [02:23:28]:
Oh, did I see?

Leo Laporte [02:23:30]:
There is more. More radioactivity.

Paris Martineau [02:23:33]:
The CP or CBP also detected radiation of cesium 137 at in a shipment of cloves from the same island Java in Indonesia. And this was at a level 10 times higher than the shrimp. I know. I would just say keep your keep your eye on the Internet. There may be more news coming.

Leo Laporte [02:24:00]:
You know, this is really going to cut into the vast Christmas market of people who put cloves and oranges. And I think this could be problematic for the holiday season. So we're going to follow this with great interest.

Jeff Jarvis [02:24:10]:
You look very smart with the process.

Paris Martineau [02:24:13]:
You look like you're a designer.

Leo Laporte [02:24:18]:
Thank you, Paris. Jeff Jarvis, of course, at Montclair State University and SUNY Stony Brook. His books, the Gutenberg Parenthesis Magazine and the Web We Weave, available at better bookstores. Thank you, both of you. Thanks to all of you for joining us. We'll see you next time.

Paris Martineau [02:24:35]:
Time.

Leo Laporte [02:24:36]:
Oh, they're very intelligent.

Paris Martineau [02:24:42]:
If you're listening only on audio, this is really bad for you.

Leo Laporte [02:24:45]:
We're all eating our glasses. Thank you, everybody. Bye. All right. Intelligent, intelligent machines. I'm not a shoe.