Hands-On Tech 293 Transcript
Please be advised that this transcript is AI-generated and may not be word-for-word. Time codes refer to the approximate times in the ad-free version of the show.
Mikah Sargent [00:00:00]:
Coming up on Hands-On Tech, a fitting end for our call for help show. Why would a printer need ink just to scan a piece of paper? I'll answer that next. Stay tuned. Hello and welcome to this, the final episode of Hands-On Tech. It has been an absolute pleasure to answer your questions for all this time and to bring you this show each and every week. But unfortunately, this show is coming to a close. I'm not going to get super into depth about it, but understand that I'll still be here.
Mikah Sargent [00:00:50]:
I'll still be doing Tech News Weekly. I will still be doing Hands-On AI, and I look forward to bringing you those shows as well. But I thought that as we round out this show that was born of a certain radio show from so long ago that Leo Laporte hosted, and then I many, many, many, many, many years later joined him as co-host on, it is now time to answer a question. Near and dear to my heart. And this question comes in from Phyllis. Phyllis writes, I bought cheaper ink cartridges online and my printer flat-out rejected them. An error about non-genuine supplies, and now it won't even scan, which as far as I know takes no ink whatsoever. That was the last straw.
Mikah Sargent [00:01:54]:
The thing is offline half the time, the ink costs more than champagne, and the company keeps nagging me to sign up for a monthly cartridge subscription. How did printers get like this, and how is any of it legal? I'm ready to replace it, but I don't want to walk into the same trap. Mostly I print shipping labels, school forms, and the occasional boarding pass, with a photo for the fridge once in a blue moon. People keep saying, just get a laser printer. Is that the answer for someone like me, or does it depend? On what you print? Phyllis, who has written in from Knoxville, Tennessee. Hi, Phyllis. Phyllis, let's start with the short answer. I always like to start with the short answer, and the short answer is this.
Mikah Sargent [00:02:42]:
Much like a lot of modern products that have subscriptions and tie-ins and everything else, the printer was never the product. It was a facilitator for the product, which is ink. Printer makers sell the machine cheap and often sell it at a loss, and then they earn that money back by selling the cartridges. So when they were not able to continue to subsidize the cost of the printers because of people buying third-party ink, they had to figure out a way to handle it. So every lockout, every nag, every non-genuine error, it's just there because the printer is doing its job to protect the printing company's ink money. That's what it is. As for what you print, the just get a laser crowd is right. I am part of the just get a laser crowd.
Mikah Sargent [00:03:50]:
A black and white laser printer Wow. It could be great. And as for your fridge photo, well, why not send that off to the drugstore or to another print service somewhere else? Let's get into it, though. Let's talk about this. Let's break it down. First and foremost, why are printers like this? Well, it's because, as we said, Above. The ink is the business. This is razor blades, right? You sell the handle cheap and then you make the money on refills.
Mikah Sargent [00:04:29]:
People have dealt with that. In fact, this is pretty incredible. I found HP's CEO actually said this himself on CNBC in January of 2024. He said the ink is where the money comes back. HP loses money on printer sales and makes it back on supplies. His words were, if a customer, quote, doesn't print enough or doesn't use our supplies, it's a bad investment, close quote. So as you might imagine, uh, HP's stated goal is Our long-term objective is to make printing a subscription. I have one, it's right over there, my HP printer that has an ink printing subscription.
Mikah Sargent [00:05:29]:
And the second that you look at it wrong, it locks you out. It's wild the way that this has changed, Phyllis. So you're not alone in feeling this way. I mean, yeah, that tells you everything you need to know. HP CEO went ahead and said it all right to you. Make printing a subscription. That is why when you get the box on your— you get the box, you bring it into your house, you set it down. That is why the box was cheap and why the company keeps nagging.
Mikah Sargent [00:06:09]:
It's why Televisions on the whole have been less expensive and why they use means of learning about you to sell that information to make money that way. You're a customer that they haven't made money on yet if you're a person who hasn't joined the subscription service. And HP, as I said, all the way in. The HP All-In plan is what it's called. It rents you the printer. And the ink monthly. And if you cancel the all-in plan, you can't use the printer anymore. You actually have to send it back to HP.
Mikah Sargent [00:06:48]:
So it's a full-on rental. I am not as far as that, thank goodness. Mine is an ink subscription service, and it is not tied to the printer. I purchased that beforehand. But I still tell you this is sort of a risk factor to be aware of. That thing is a pain. And well, we'll get to it, but the laser printer that I have in the other room, that's the one that we use all the time. All right, let's move along.
Mikah Sargent [00:07:23]:
First and foremost, you— or next and foremost, I guess— you talked about non-genuine supplies. So when your printer is saying some form of, hey, Uh, this is, this is non-genuine, or this is non— it isn't certified, whatever it happens to be. It doesn't actually mean that the ink is fake or that the ink is faulty. That's often, I think, what it sounds like. It just means that, look, the chip that's on the cartridge isn't the printer maker's. So when you put that cartridge into your printer, it reads a little chip on there and says, oh yeah, I know you, you're good. And if it's not on there, then it doesn't print. And these companies will say all sorts of reasons why, uh, this is the case, but the fact is the cartridges have a little chip and the printer just checks it before it'll print.
Mikah Sargent [00:08:27]:
HP in fact spells it out on its own page saying that certain printers use Dynamic security measures to block cartridges using a non-HP chip or electronic circuitry. I can remember not being able to afford new ink cartridges growing up, and so at the time, the chips that were inside of these were a little bit easier to get at, and I had orchestrated a way to sort of lay the chip along the third-party cartridge and get it to run in the printer, but it would only run sometimes, and it would often mess up the print in the middle of it. These things are a pain, and that hasn't changed. And Frankly, they don't necessarily have an incentive to make things that much better. HP also goes on to say periodic firmware updates will maintain the effectiveness of these measures and block cartridges that previously worked. So even if you've had a printer that's happily taken that cheaper ink for a year, for, you know, for about a year, But usually you're going to see firmware updates maybe even more frequently than that. You get this overnight update and boom, now that cartridge that worked before is suddenly not working again. The reason that they give out loud is different from the reason that is the true— well, that we would argue is an important reason.
Mikah Sargent [00:10:09]:
I can't say it's the true reason, but it's an important reason. HP says publicly the reason is security. The CEO said that cartridges could carry viruses, and security researchers, by the way, found that risk to everyday users is vanishingly small. We'll link to a PC World piece that I looked at that talks about the conversation, or the, yeah, the interview with the HP CEO and some of the ridiculousness therein. If you keep a printer that takes your cheaper ink, Just figure out if you can turn off its automatic firmware updates. That does mean that you may miss out on security fixes, and so there are some people who are cringing at that suggestion. But if you can keep it as a local printer and avoid losing access to the ink that you paid for, then maybe that's worth it. Phyllis, you also asked, you know, a question that really kind of made me go, yeah, this doesn't make sense, which was, why is my printer that's complaining about ink not letting me scan? I thought that scanning didn't require ink.
Mikah Sargent [00:11:30]:
Fair, given that this is something that the printer is doing. But I'll tell you, you're right, scanning uses no ink. Many all-in-ones will actually lock up every function when there's a cartridge error. They'll do so when it says it's empty. They'll do so when they get the non-genuine error, and that means locking up the scanner as well. But they can't get away with this all the time. Canon got sued over this in 2021. There was a PIXMA owner who found that his all-in-one wouldn't scan or fax when ink ran low.
Mikah Sargent [00:12:07]:
And so in the suit, The person argued that there's, quote, no reason or technical basis for it. Unfortunately, then Canon changed and changed its support and said to owners that ink must be installed to use the printer's feature. The other lookouts that you might— or lockouts rather, not lookouts, but lockouts that you might want to be aware of is the thing that I have a subscription to. That is HP Instant Ink. If you do cancel your Instant Ink subscription, HP will remotely disable those cartridges that are in your printer, even if they're full. So you can't use them. They will remotely disable them. You have to send them back or— whatever HP tells you to do with them, and then you have to buy the non-subscription cartridges.
Mikah Sargent [00:13:06]:
And here's the thing, the subscription cartridges are marketed as being higher capacity. And it is convenient, I will say, to have the ink come to me as soon as the previous ink is running out. But there was a time where that was not something I could afford. And so suddenly not being able to use my printer because I can't afford new ink, I might as well be renting it. Very fortunate. Very unfortunate. And then there's HP+. Uh, HP+ requires an HP account, internet connection, and use of original HP ink for the lifetime of the printer.
Mikah Sargent [00:13:45]:
Once it's activated, it stays on for good. Any non-HP ink will not work. Because of HP+. So HP+, Instant Ink, and then also a wrong cartridge can switch off other functionality of an all-in-one device. You asked an important question, a question that I have to say I'm not a lawyer, and so bear that in mind. But what does the law actually have to say about this, and what does it cover, what doesn't it cover? Well, The short version is they can't— the law can't punish you for using other ink, but the makers of the printers don't have to make a printer that accepts the ink. So if you figure out a way, sort of, if you figure out a way and don't publish it and share it around and To use a third-party ink, then wow, you've done it. But as far as the company, it's a trade-off.
Mikah Sargent [00:15:06]:
They don't have to make the printer that will say, yeah, yeah, yeah, put in this third-party cartridge. There are also ways that they can keep things in your control. And that includes a warranty. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act of 1975 bans tie-in sales provisions. A warranty can't say you must use the maker's supplies to stay covered unless they give them to you free or get an FTC waiver. They can deny a repair If third-party ink actually caused the damage. So if you have used third-party ink in your printer and they can confirm that you have, you're going to have a heck of a time getting it covered. But on the face of it, it's not allowed for the company to void your warranty.
Mikah Sargent [00:16:08]:
over your successful use of other ink. What about refilling a cartridge that you bought? That's something else I've done, sticking a needle in and filling that cartridge up. In, I think it was a, let's see, it's the Supreme Court actually. The Supreme Court settled it in Impression Products versus Lexmark on May 30th, 2017. A patentee's decision to sell a product, this is a little bit of legalese, But bear with me here. A patentee's decision to sell a product exhausts all of its patent rights in that item, regardless of any restrictions the patentee purports to impose. So what does that all mean in our language? Once you buy the cartridge, then it's yours to refill if you want to. And again, that's the Impression Products, Inc.
Mikah Sargent [00:17:05]:
versus Lexmark International, Inc. Then what the law does and doesn't cover. Well, a chip can be blocked with an update. It is allowed for now. So bricking is allowed, blocking chips with firmware. No law says a printer must accept every cartridge. So that is kind of where the fight from one side or the other is for Phyllis and for HP. HP actually was hit with a federal class action in 2024 over updates that blocked cartridges that used to work.
Mikah Sargent [00:17:44]:
Until a court or a lawmaker says otherwise, the printer continues to get to be picky. So we've tried to make changes there and tried to stop the bricking especially, but it hasn't made much of a difference. And perhaps that's because printers are still so frustrating and annoying, and so we don't spend enough time around them to think Goodness gracious, I wish this thing just worked. Um, moving along to the printer offline thing, right? Where to find the, um, the stuck printer. Now, Phyllis, you also mentioned that you would regularly see your printer offline. That's another issue I've run into as well. Uh, but I've got some advice for you. Usually if your printer is offline, it's not because the printer is dying.
Mikah Sargent [00:18:34]:
It's just that the computer that you're using has somehow lost track of it. It can be, you know, via Wi-Fi, it's lost track. If the printer went to— this happens all the time with my Brother printer— the printer napped and it dropped off the network, the router decided to hand it a new address if you don't have the IP reserved, a print job jammed the queue— that can actually happen— or somehow Sure, you could have toggled on— well, off networking access through some means. It's not a very common thing, but it is something to bear in mind. To find a stuck printer that you hope is still around somewhere, in Windows, you click the Start menu, you go to Settings, you go to Bluetooth and Devices, Printers and Scanners, you choose your printer, and then open that print queue. Cancel any stuck jobs. On Windows 10, you can also clear pause printing and use printer offline. We really want to make sure use printer offline is not selected.
Mikah Sargent [00:19:38]:
If it's still stuck, restart the print spooler service or remove the printer and add it back. And we'll include a link in the show notes to a Microsoft guide that has more on fixing printers for when the show is over. And In macOS, you can go into the Apple menu, System Settings, Printers and Scanners, and then add the printer from there. So I like to, uh, try and make sure that my printer has the most recent software available, the most recent firmware available, and is also regularly showing up in the printers and scanners section on macOS. If it isn't, then I know that there's probably a network issue that I need to address instead. Again, I can't state this enough. A real big fix when it comes to printers and having the issues that you might have with them, just reserve the printer's IP address in your router. If you don't know how to do that, you can type in the model of your router and then type in IP address reservation or reserve IPs, something like that, and you should be able to find it.
Mikah Sargent [00:20:59]:
Or check out my show, Hands-On AI, and you can learn about how to use AI to help you with that. Or you can also plug it in with USB or Ethernet. if it's sitting next to the computer. It doesn't have to be wireless, but I like mine wireless. And moving on to your next question, you asked, why does ink cost more than champagne? Well, Consumer Reports actually did the math, and it turns out that the cheapest, at the time, replacement cartridge ink runs at about $13 an ounce. That's more than twice the price of Dom Pérignon. And it's— this is the thing— the priciest ink is actually closer to $95 an ounce. $95 an ounce.
Mikah Sargent [00:21:49]:
And this is something frustrating that I had to learn for you, Phyllis. A lot of it never touches paper. I kind of thought about this conceptually when I've taken apart printers before, but I didn't really put it all together in such a way. Inkjets spend ink all the time. They spend ink cleaning their printheads, especially after they sit idle. And they spray ink all over the place. In CR's intermittent use tests, many inkjets put half or less of their ink on the page. A few even managed 20 to 30%.
Mikah Sargent [00:22:27]:
Uh, one individual from Consumer Reports said it's typical for an inkjet to use as much ink on maintenance as it does on printing. And that is you, Phyllis. That's a few labels and forms a week. That's the pattern that ends up wasting the most ink. So let's break it down. The math goes even deeper, uh, with CR's buying guide. Cartridge inkjet, $70 Or more. A black and white laser toner cartridge, about $15.
Mikah Sargent [00:23:11]:
By the way, this is for a year of printing. I'm sorry, I should start that out. Um, I may have mentioned it, but a year of printing costs for a cartridge inkjet, $70 or more. Black and white laser toner, about $15. And the newer type of printer, the ink tank printer, less than $10. Hallelujah! Um, some— why, why is this the case? And why do black and white laser toner printers cost so much less? Well, lasers don't need to do maintenance, make use of maintenance ink at all. It's a dry powder toner. And so It's already dry.
Mikah Sargent [00:23:59]:
It doesn't dry out sitting on the shelf. It doesn't need to squirt through the printheads and try to get some moisture back into the system. No, it's a dry powder, so it's good to go. Now, should you go with the laser or the inkjet? Which one is right for you? I There's a reason I have both. I do make use of the color printer with the crafting stuff that I do, but it just depends on what you print and for what you print. For what you print specifically, laser wins because shipping labels, school forms, boarding passes— these are black and white documents. You get crisp text. It's real fast.
Mikah Sargent [00:24:48]:
It comes out nice and warm. It's cheap per page. It can sit idle for weeks. Mine sits idle for weeks. And then if you get a multifunction inkjet— not inkjet, but laser, sorry— if you get a multifunction laser, then you'll have a scanner. Uh, in— see, from Consumer Reports, says monochrome lasers do what most people actually use a printer for: sharp black and white text, and tend to be more reliable than inkjets. It's what I've been saying this whole time. If you do print with lots of color— kids' projects, flyers, frequent photos— that's where an ink tank printer might be the way you go.
Mikah Sargent [00:25:37]:
You can refill the ink tanks from bottles instead of buying cartridges. CR said there's an estimate of about $5 a year in ink for some models. It does cost more, Upfront, which makes sense, $250 or more. Epson is well known for its ink tank printers. But for you, if you've got the fridge photo every once in a while, once in a blue moon, an online print service or a local drugstore that's still doing prints, it's cheaper than keeping that color inkjet alive for one photo. And you get better paper along with it. $70 or more versus $10 at the grocery store. If you're doing lots of shipping labels, you may consider going with a thermal labor— label printer, and maybe that can be kind of an extension of the laser printer.
Mikah Sargent [00:26:39]:
It doesn't use ink, it doesn't use toner, It's just heat that is applied to the label that then darkens. And so that could be something that is worth doing. But be aware that depending on which model of thermal label printer you get, you may have one like Dymo which says it works exclusively with its own labels. So you may find some of that lock-in in other places, but certainly with a nice, beautiful laser printer, you can be a-okay. That said, and this is We'll round it out after this. It doesn't mean that a laser is automatically just trap-free. I have mentioned I've ran into a couple of issues with mine because for HP, its chip check also covers its laser toner as well. So depending on the company, you may still have the same issue.
Mikah Sargent [00:28:02]:
Before you buy, search the model name and then search third-party toners. See what owners say about it, and if the setup screen offers HP Plus, if it offers an ink subscription— my brother has tried to get me to do an ink subscription. Well, not tried, I've seen, uh, when I go in to do a firmware update, it pop up there. You can skip it. And with HP Plus, you gotta skip it. It's the only way out. Say no to anything that asks for an account just to print. Leave the new printer on rather than switching it off after every job.
Mikah Sargent [00:28:37]:
That's one big thing to bear in mind. Uh, and CR found that that cuts the startup cleaning cycles on inkjets, and it costs very little power to keep it running. So turning it off and then turning back on means it's running all the time, and it's thinking that it needs to clean itself again, because they always think they need to clean themselves because they're always drying out and they're always getting clogged. Let's get to the bottom line here. Non-genuine supplies, as you heard or saw or read, means not our chip. It doesn't mean that, that the ink is bad. The printer is sold cheap. The cartridges pay for it.
Mikah Sargent [00:29:24]:
You pay for it through the cartridges. It is legal to block a cartridge, but it is not legal to void your warranty for using one. And with caveats. And refilling a cartridge you brought— excuse me, refilling a cartridge you bought is your right. And you gotta fight for your right to party. For labels, for forms, for boarding passes, I think you're good getting a black and white laser multifunction. And then just send that fridge photo off to get printed somewhere. Whatever you buy, just please skip HP Plus and ink subscriptions unless you're sure you want them for the life of the printer.
Mikah Sargent [00:30:08]:
Don't get stuck in something you don't want. And now, unfortunately, it is time for me to become unstuck from this chair and this show because I'm pulling away. The ship is leaving. Hands-on tech. Is sailing away. No, it's been a true joy to get to answer your questions. I do still hope to answer many of your questions in different places. Hands-On AI is one of those places, but also in the club, twitch.tv/clubtwit.
Mikah Sargent [00:30:46]:
We'd love to have you. You know what? Let's get cozy. This has been Hands-On Tech. I have been Micah Sargent. This has been a very long video. for printers, and I couldn't be more satisfied. Have a lovely rest of your holiday season, or if it's just kicking off for you. And I do certainly hope that you will join me on Tech News Weekly, on Hands-On AI, and on other things in the future. Stay tuned. Bye-bye.