Deciding the Right Storage Size for Your Computer

AI-created, human-reviewed.

In a recent episode of Hands-On Tech, host Mikah Sargent tackled an interesting question from listener Dustin: how much storage is enough for a family Mac? This question highlights a common consideration for households looking to invest in a shared computer that will accommodate multiple users.

Dustin explained that after inheriting a 2008 iMac and using it as a kitchen computer, he's now in the market for an M4 iMac replacement. His main concern centered around storage capacity, specifically whether 256GB would be sufficient for a computer that both he and his wife would use with separate iCloud accounts. While they planned to primarily use cloud storage and only pull data as needed, Dustin was unsure how macOS handles multiple users with different iCloud accounts on a single machine.

Mikah's response drew from his personal experience managing multiple macOS accounts on his own computers. He explained that even with cloud-based storage settings enabled, each user account on a Mac creates its own home folder containing application settings, cache files, and user-specific data. This results in more storage consumption than many users anticipate when setting up multiple accounts.

"The problem is, each instance of a macOS account is going to have its own home folder that is going to include different applications and application settings and cache files and all sorts of stuff that are specific to that user," Mikah noted in the episode. This duplication of system files can quickly eat into available storage space.

Another important consideration Mikah highlighted was the behavior of various applications. Web browsers like Chrome or Safari, media streaming apps, and video conferencing tools all cache data differently. Even when configured to store most content in the cloud, these applications inevitably store temporary files locally. With two users running separate instances of these applications, storage requirements can increase substantially.

Perhaps the most compelling reason to opt for more storage comes down to convenience. Mikah pointed out that, unlike some other aspects of a computer, storage capacity is fixed at purchase for Macs. "Once you have the storage space selected, that's it, that's all. It's there, it's done, and so because of that, you can't really undo a boo-boo," he explained. This means if you underestimate your needs, you'll be stuck managing storage constraints or relying on external drives.

While Mikah acknowledged that 256GB might be sufficient for basic web browsing, media consumption, and video chatting, he ultimately recommended bumping up to 512GB if the budget allows. This extra space provides a buffer that prevents the inconvenience of constantly managing storage between multiple accounts. There's nothing more frustrating than sitting down to use your computer only to discover you need to free up space before proceeding.

Mikah did note that Dustin's experience with his current 2008 iMac could provide valuable insight. If that machine has 256GB of storage and has served the family well without space issues, then perhaps the same capacity would work for the new iMac. However, without knowing the current iMac's specifications, Mikah leaned toward recommending the larger storage option for peace of mind.

For families considering a shared Mac, this advice offers a practical guideline: when multiple users are involved, consider stepping up to the next storage tier. The convenience of not having to micromanage storage space between accounts is likely worth the additional investment, especially considering that storage cannot be upgraded later in most modern Macs.